BloodHorse.com Blogs

I was watching the Kentucky Derby, Saturday. What a great race! But my heart fell to the ground after seeing Eight Belles laying on the ground. My heart goes out to all the people involved with her. It was a tragic loss. I thing the horses should be wearing some kind of support wraps on their legs. Of all the equine sports.......racing doesn't have them. My daughter barrel races and does speed events and wouldn't run the horse without them. And she is a veternarian.  It may not prevent all injuries but I believe it could help. I really want to attend a Derby someday but now I'm not so sure I want too. These equines give their everything for our enjoyment. At least we could try to give them something in return.......like support on their legs. A horse that young, the legs are still developing and what they do, has got to be some of the reasons whey they breakdown. I just thought I'd send my opinion and idea. Again, my condolences to the Eight Belles and company. And congrats to the winner. Hopefully he can do it this year. Got my fingers crossed.

I watched the race Ruffian broke down in. I quit watching racing after that - until Funny Cide.  Now I've seen Pine Island, Barbaro, Mending Fences, George Washington, and Eight Belles. The good things like Funny Cide and Smarty Jones got me watching again. Now I'm thinking I need to turn away again. Can seeing a triple crown winner be worth all this? I guess that makes me a "bleeding heart". The comment "oh that's just a part of racing" seems so hollow.  If this is a part  of racing, does it have to keep being a part of racing? I know once they break a leg it's too late. Is there some kind of intervention possible before that point? If I thought the powers that be in racing were still looking, it would help.  But turning a cold shoulder is not enough.  Maybe racing deserves to loose followers. Think about it.

With the loss of Eight Belles, yet another major race day was marred by tragedy. We saw Chelokee and the filly breakdown on Derby weekend. The last four Breeder’s Cups have had breakdowns, the most recent ones being George Washington, Pine Island, and Fleet Indian.

One has to ask, why so many breakdowns in the U.S.? What is the impact on racing fans? Have we drugged horses for so many years that the gene pool is weakened?

As an industry, the comment “That’s racing…” doesn’t cut it any more. We need answers and solutions if this sport is to survive and the athletes, who put their lives on the line each day, are to thrive. I can guarantee you that if the fatality rates were proportionately as high in football as in racing, the sport would be banned.

There is still another issue that is not getting enough attention, the fate of retiring and injured horses on the lower end of racing – the claimers. These horses have fought their way through dozens of races, several owners, and declining careers, only to end up like Cappucino Kid, on his way to a Mexican slaughterhouse before being rescued in the eleventh hour.

I have been an avid fan of racing for years, but I am increasingly disheartened by the accidents and the lack of retirement planning for these heroic athletes. More frequently I find myself watching Standardbred racing, where breakdowns seldom happen.

I live in Maine where there are few people who follow thoroughbred racing.  It gets lonely out here, especially when tragedy strikes, as it did today.  I watch horse racing every day on HRTV and TVG, and every time they go to the post I ask the gods to make it a safe race.  I am not religious, so I pray to all the gods.  The last two years have been tough--Pine Island,  George Washington, Barbaro and always distant memories of Ruffian. Friday was tough with Michael Matz's horse Chelokee.  I just wanted the Kentucky Derby to be without injury.  Not to be.  Immediately I asked myself why I watch thoroughbred racing.   As soon as the horses ran under the finish line my daughter called me to say what a great race Eight Belles ran and how proud we were of her.  Two minutes later we were on the phone again wondering why we watch horse racing when things like this happen.  We always question running two year olds, especially with a big horse like Eight Belles.  In the end, we recognized that we love our dogs, our cats and the horses we have owned, one of whom lost her life after suffering a broken leg from a kick by another horse in the field.  We recognized that we would never trade the joy that each and every one of these animals brought to our lives.  We recognized that animals have brought us such companionship and happiness in our lives that we would continue to follow the sport. But, at the same time we hope and support continued vigilance and research to lessen these kinds of catastrophic injuries.  We never forget the horses, who are not famous, who  give their heart and soul in the sport of racing.  We mourn the loss of Eight Belles and urge the entire industry to search endlessly for better answers to lessen these catastrophic injuries and in so doing honor Barbaro, Ruffian, Pine Island, Eight Belles,  and the thousands of other horses who have given their all and lifted our spirits.  We especially send our most heartfelt condolences to the owners, trainer and jockey of Eight Belles.

I was cheering for Eight Belles since she was the only filly running in the Kentucky Derby only to be saddened by this tragedy.  She really did run the race of her life and she will always have a place in my heart.  My sympathies go out to the trainer, the owners and all who played a part in her racing career.

This year I watched my twelfth Derby with one of my good friends who is a big sports fan in general but had never taken any interest in horse racing.  I explained many things to her about the Derby from graded stakes earnings, to jockeys to why I thought Colonel John was at a disadvantage despite his stellar track record on synthetic surfaces.  I told her that the Derby experience would mean a lot more to her if she picked a horse to root for.  She agreed and picked Eight Belles (I picked Tale of Ekati).  Into the stretch both of us were cheering hard for Eight Belles.  Being a veteran of Barbaro I knew what was coming when the camera showed the stricken filly lying on the track after her courageous effort.  After answering every question my friend asked me about the Kentucky Derby and racing the only one I couldn't answer was, why did such a magnificent horse die?  We will still be great friends but I don't think we will watch the Preakness together.

You gave us such a thrill. You gave us your all... We will forever keep you in our hearts. God Speed "Belle"

What a beautiful horse and bless her for running so hard to come in second.  We will always remember the valiant effort she gave until the end.  We would have loved to see you race again and the memory of you running for your life will always be with us.

We will see you at the Rainbow Bridge.

Eight Belles was such a beautiful filly.  She was outstanding in the Derby running her heart out and beating 18 males.  For a few precious seconds I almost dreamed she might catch the big guy. No matter.  She is a true chamipion.  I don't think I will ever forget jumping up and down and screaming so hard when she came in second behind Big Brown.  It was so short lived.  Her fall and death hit me so hard as I know it has everyone especially her connections.  I won't ever forget her.  RIP sweet girl.

The greatest sport in the world I lived for 45 years. The highest of highs and the lowest of lows were displayed all in one minute. I miss the highs but not those lows as shown Saturday.

I know all about it as a wonderful gray filly was 10 minutes from being a champion at Belmont Park Breeders Cup but it was gone in a minute as something spooked her and she flip over injuring her head. She died 5 days later in her stall at Belmont Park barn 31.

My heart go out to Larry Jones and Tom Porter for their lost because it hurts as I have lived it.

Up through an empty house of stars,

Being what heart you are,

Up the inhuman steeps of space

As on a staircase go in grace,

Carrying the firelight on your face

Beyond the loneliest star.

Farewell, gallant spirit.  You were a true Thoroughbred.

I think this was a bizarre incident, but weird things happen when you are asking two and three year olds to push their limits.

Eight Belles was a big, growthy filly that pushed herself to the extreme. Obviously she had tremendous heart and drive. Obviously she was not ready for the task. Big Brown is a bruiser and nobody was going to catch him on Saturday. I truly think he is phenomenal and will be hard for anyone to catch over the next 5 weeks.

But Eight Belles gave it her best. I think she was running on adrenaline at the end and (in my mind anyway) most likely sustained an injury to one ankle in the stretch drive---which was one brutal dash. She and the rest of the pack looked like those racing greyhounds trying to catch "Lucky". She continued galloping out, injured it further and then hurt her other ankle trying to "save herself". These horses will keep trying to run no matter what, that's what they are bred to do. Not all jockeys have the luck/strength/tenacity of Edgar Prado (when he pulled Barbaro up). A lot of the time, these horses hurt themselves and just keep "flying" on heart and adrenaline, the jockey may not realize it until "reality" crashes in. It is not fair to place blame on Gabriel Saez.

In fact, its no one's "fault". And that is probably the hardest thing to accept about this. The filly was loved and well-cared for and everyone thought she had a shot at the Roses. NO ONE in her connections ever dreamed of this. I think the people around her are good people and Larry Jones is best known for his prowess with fillies and mares, he is one of the best when it comes to running "the girls". I honestly think if soundness had been an issue with the filly prior to the race, they would NOT have run her. Her connections are very intelligent and well-respected. And after the very public and long-drawn out Barbaro ordeal, horse racing itself did not need another "black eye" on NBC Sports on a Saturday afternoon.

But, no one could have predicted this. Breakdowns occur around the world on a daily basis, both during races and in training.  They just aren't so public as this and Barbaro was.

May there be a field of sweet clover in Heaven for her.

She was such a gorgeous filly... I will never forget cheering, out loud, "She's going to come in second!!!!!!!!"

I will never, ever forget Eight Belles.

My heart fell when I saw that poor filly on the ground. I knew instantly.....she was dead. I love horse racing but have always believed that it's not they are pushed too hard (as PETA wants all to believe), it is that they are pushed too soon.  I've been a firm believer that racing can continue, but should be delayed until 3-4 years of age when these beautiful creatures have a chance to have their growth plates fuse and their bones strengthen. Yes, there are some trainers that push too hard (hey, every industry has their abusers), but the problem lies in not taking into account that the thoroughbreds bound for the track grow at a faster rate than horses bred to remain as family pets. Race horses are given supplements and outstanding feed and their growth spurts are phenomenal. Unfortunately, they are not given the chance to develop propertly before they are stressed with the rigors of training and racing.  Let racing continue for the beauty of it and the fact that many of these animals do indeed love what they do; but please give them the chance to develop to avoid these tragedies.

Eight Belles you will be remembered along with Barbaro.

I'm sorry Belle.  You didn't deserve this ending.  Like Barbaro, there was a higher purpose for you.  You will always be missed and loved.  My deepest sympathies to you, your trainer and owner.

I was, as all who watched, shocked to see the breakdown of this filly, who had seemingly had a great day.

My heart goes out to those who loved her. However, this is becoming too common in racing, and attention should be paid to more by way of prevention. I am not convinced this conclusion was not preventable. She deserved better. Enough said.

Alot of people can't get past the sadness regarding Eight Belles.  Myself included.  I still have a hardtimte regarding Barbaro and I have followed Chelokee since his 3 year old campaign.  It's very upsetting to see a horse breakdown let alone be euthanized on the track.  I feel that i have to reach out to these owners who make serious money on their horses.  I read about Cappuchino Kid being rescued.  Don't these owners have a game plan about retirement after racing or breeding?  It makes me want to play Lotto everyday so I can buy a farm in upstate NY for a retirement horse santuary that would not just be for Thoroughbreds.  Owners need to please think about their horse's futures.  It makes me sick every time I think about Ferdinand. I hope you put this on the site so other people can read and think about it.

Eight Belles ran her heart and her life out on Saturday.  She proved she belonged in the race with the boys.  I'm heartbroken at how it ended.  

What to do with the heartbreak?  Press and hope for changes and innovations in the sport to make it safer.  And, perhaps even more importantly, go save another one.  Beautiful Eight Belles is gone, but somewhere there's a Thoroughbred leaving the racetrack who doesn't have to die.  Send something to TB Friends, CANTER, or ReRun in her honor.  

My heart is breaking...again.

Ruffian

Go For Wand

Exogenous

Pine Island

Eight Belles

I'm heartsick over the passing of Eight Belles. She was a magnificent beauty who did not deserve the ending she got.  She finished first in my book.  I just wish I could stop being so sad for her and her connections.  I can't get though a single day so far without thinking of her.  :(

I was very saddened to see Eight Belles go down after the Derby and the end result was tragic.I thinks the track surfaces maybe where the answer is in preventing this from happening.When Earnhardt died Nascar has been focused on keeping the drivers safe.The best way to honor these great thoroughbreds is making the changes so future mishaps with such heart wrenching results do not occur.I hope Eight Belles was told how much she was loved and how great she was.

She was beautiful, poised beyond her years, and had the heart of a champion. I can't imagine watching another race after being so thrilled over her wonderful effort, then to see her gone in the blink of an eye. Is anything worth the loss of such a magnificent, innocent creature? Belle, you will love on in all of our memories, and your spirit runs free still. Rest in peace.

It was truely a sad day. It was a  tragic loss.  Horses end up being like children to us. Watching them grow up we see there querks and know there personalities and when something like this happen our heart breaks. My heart broke and when I heard of Eight Belles's break down I wept. In a situation like this people need not think about how she died but celebrate how she lived. Eight Belles was a magnificient horse and I will remember her forever. I know horses break down in the sport and it is very very sad. I called my mother after the race not to talk about Big Brown winning because he was the horse I was rooting for but to see how she was holding up after the break down. I got her on the phone and she was crying for Eight Belles.Eight Belles ran a great race and is now in a better place running through green pastures with the great race horses of past. She knows we love her and that we did not mean any harm. She knows that all we wanted was to admire and appreciate her as she ran beautifully down the track.  

Eight Belles was the greatest three year old filly I ever saw race, which is somthing considering I have been a serious fan for more than 30 years.  I do most sincerely hope that her death will not be in vain, but rather, be used in a POSITIVE way to promote change in our industry.  While there are many strong opinions on dirt vs. synthetic surfaces, and further, while there are other factors (over medication, breeding for speed, etc.) which contribute to catostropic breakdowns, I believe it is time that the leader of the racetrack industry (Churchill Downs) to "act" or "lead" and make the surface switch.  The larger issue is not whether one prominent trainer/owner is for or against synthetic surfaces, but rather, whether our sport can be saved from the terrible negative perception of the public that is fostered when horses breakdown on national TV (Barbaro, Pine Island, Eight Belles).  I have great respect for Bob Baffert and Nick Zito as trainers, and I am open minded enought to listen to any trainer who does not blindly follow the party line, as it were, in favor of synthetics.  No doubt we are still in the middle of a learning curve when it comes to synthetics (less breakdowns but an increase soft tissue injuries).  But when compared to the public relatins disaster that has occurred in our sport, the dissenting opinions are simply unavailing.  Unequivocally, the easiest (and quickest) thing that can be done to lessen breakdowns is to make the switch to a synthetic surface.  Now is the time to act, as our industry is risking the elimination of a whole generation of fans if we sit around and "collect data."  It is my hope and desire that Eight Belles be remembered for ALL that she contributed to our industry; that is, her brillance as a race filly AND as a tipping point/catalyst for change to softer surfaces.      

Rest in Peace girl.

 You were a truly amazing animal!

 Love You......

My heart goes out to Eight Belles.  I am so sorry this happened to you.  You did such a wonderful job at the derby.  I am so sorry your life was cut so short by such a terrible tragedy.  I have thought of you countless times over the past few days, and will continue to do so.  

Three beautiful horses in much greener and happier pastures. Ruffian,Go for Wand, Eight Bell.I will never forget them.

I agree w/ Susan.  This sport is simply asking too much of immature skeletal structures.  Wait one more year and these breakdowns and heartaches will lesson.

Please hear us all of you horse racing business owners - we want to support the sport, but not at this price. Please reconsider.

I had the opportunity to see Eight Belles run at the Fairgrounds 01/21/08.  Mr. Jones himself walked her around the paddock and I could see how special she was to him.  I feel blessed to have seen her.  My heartfelt prayers go out to all her connections and Gabriel, keep your head up high.

Eight Belles, say hello to my dad.

Nearing the end of the Derby it was obvious that Big Brown was going to win. (TC finally??) However I was just as excited to see Eight Belles coming through the pack and taking over 2nd-we were all yelling "look, the filly is gonna be second"  As she crossed the line she was running gamely with her ears pricked, doing what she loved doing-being a racehorse. That is how I will always remember Eight Belles. Rest in Peace, sweet girl-you will never be forgotten.

Eight Belles,  We have lost a true champion many years before your time.  I will always remember your great derby, always be haunted by your tragic accident. I've heard Kent Desormeaux say many times that his mount "gave me his life today", not meaning that literally but figuratively.  You did that for your trainer, your owner, your jockey, your groom, and us, your fans.  

May you run in heaven's lush green pastures with Barbaro, Pine Island, George Washington, and the thousands of other horses who gave their life on the track.

Eight Belles was a true champion and had a bunch of followers that thought she could win the Kentucky Derby. Going into the Kentucky Derby and trying to become the fourth filly to win the Run for the Roses was a challenge in itself. She ran the race of her life racing against the boys and she beat 18 other horses. When I seen her laying on the track, my heart just dropped and it brought back memories of Barbaro from a year ago. I also had seen Chelokee and George Washington break down and it just horrifies me. Eight Belles will be missed by all and my prayers and thoughts go out to Larry Jones, Gabreal Saez, and the owners of her. RIP sweet girl. You were the best and nobody can take that from you.

It's very unfair of PETA to pass judgement in this situation. First of all they are extemists that are not rational and they rush to judge in a lot of case. In addition they are not horse people. Furthermore, there seemed no indication watching Eight Belles coming down the stretch many yards before the finish line, that something was wrong. Things happen to horses that can go unexplained, which makes it even harder for all that love them to accept. Eight Belles will always be remembered for her heart and beauty. I can only imagine how heart broken her connections are and my sympathies are with the entire Belles family.

No one is at fault for Eight Belles' death, in fact I commend her jockey and trainer for doing such a great job with her. Horses will break down no matter what.  Horses die after kicking their stalls or even being led to their paddock (like Saint Liam).  

What the industry needs are sound, durable stallions.  Why must we breed only for speed?  More than anything, this is what needs to change.

So instead of letting this tragedy hurt the sport, we need to remember the great filly for her heart and accomplishments, and use this to finally convince breeders that soundness is just as important as speed.

I was there on Saturday.  I experienced her immortal spirit as she blazed toward the finish line while I screamed her name, wailing like the Banshee.

Eight Belles' death nearly killed me.  But not before my heart—my very soul—swelled with pride and ecstasy.  I thought I was going to explode as she roared toward home, nipping at Big Brown's heels.  

She ran her guts out.  She ran down 18 male horses.  An Amazon, a Warrior Woman, a Goddess--a living, breathing, obsessed-with-winning  Diva.   The mighty Azeri cheered  in her stall.  Winning Colors neighed her approval from her heavenly perch.   As Eight Belles breathed down Brown's neck, she spied the pantheon just up ahead.

And now--as horrible, as sad as it is--contrary to what WE think, she IS in her rightful place, in that pantheon.   Elysian Fields, the heavenly racetrack: running against Seattle Slew, Alydar, Go for Wand, Ruffian, Secretariat.   Eight Belles didn't die before she'd established herself as a Great Horse.   And, having done that--she ran, on four perfect legs--Home.

I love you, and will miss you, beautiful girl.  God rest your soul, Eight Belles.

Beautiful Girl Eight Belles.  Rest in Peace.  Though you're not here with us anymore, I will always remember you racing your heart out and giving us the thrill of seeing you flying past all those boys. What a Rush!!! What a Champ !!! What a Loss!!!

Anabolic steroids - makes them have too much ability, over and above what there bodies are designed to handle!!! How about a National Racing Authority that has authority (not just in name), like Japan, and the implementation for these trainers of three strikes and you are out (as far as medications infractions)? These three things would be an improvement on safety immediately, and make the 10 second two year old under training a thing of the past. Theses animals could develop the way they are supposed to, not hyped up on synthetics that screw up their endocrine system and hearts for the rest of their lives.

Racing is NOT doing enough to create safer conditions for the horses, and subsequently, for the small men who ride them. The amount of callousness and disregard for life for the sake of pure ego, is truly horrific.

I have been a horse racing fan since Secretariat won the triple crown. Then perfection came in the name of "Ruffian". As fate would have it, she was gone in what seemed like an instant. Horses love to run, in the wild or on a track. Eight Belles was all heart, determination and a strong will. We will never get to see how truly great she was. Eight Belles has made us all cry, for her pain, her breakdown, and for what could have been. She runs free now, out of pain, in Heaven's pasture. What a truly remarkable stable there is in Heaven! Rest in peace Eight Belles. The "Bell" tolled too soon for you, we will always remember your race of a lifetime.....the time your life was given to race. Love you forever!

I was overjoyed that Big Brown won,but when i saw Eight Belles lying motionless on the track after,i was sick with grief. I knew the minute the camera landed on her how badly she was injured and what her fate was to be. I too think that by raising the age of horses eligible to race,we could prevent this.We could also prevent injuries like Barbaro's,Eight Belles and Chelokee's if Churchill Downs switched their surface to a synthetic PolyTrack surface from dirt...My heart goes out to Eight Belles,and i have to admit..witnessing something like that turned me off from racing...RIP Eight Belles..we love you

As a person who has worked for Larry and Cindy Jones, I know that

Eight Belles was well taken care of. They would never send any horse to race if there was any chance of injury to the horse or rider.  They truly are great horsemen, and they do not deserve any criticism they are getting.

I have been watching horse racing for most of my life. I will never get used to seeing a beautiful animal have to be destroyed. As I sat there watching as she was being put down, I thought to myself why do I do this.  At that point I said no more. But I have this great love of the horse.  I am so sorry for all the people who loved Eight Belles.  She was truly a great champion.

I'll never forget the TV spot showing Larry Jones exercising Eight Belles. She seemed such an intelligent, happy filly and was obviously much cherished. To see her lying on the track was devastating.

I began crying before the Derby, a feeling of premonition coming over me. I said prayers for their safety, like so many. I can only surmise that the death of Eight Belles will have a higher purpose. Public outcry at the sight of beaten horses being whipped and great equines asked for so much too soon WILL win out. Racing should wake up. No animal lover or, as they say "pet parent", will watch a sport that kills horses. Make some changes, in the name of Eight Belles and Barbara and so many others before it is too late. I love racing and don't want to see it banned as cruelty.

I was at the Derby with my daughter.  We both had Eight Belles in our wagers and the joy of collecting was totally extinguished by the loss of this beautiful filly.  She gave her all for her owners and trainer and for all of us watching her.  Our hearts were saddened and it was the only flaw in an otherwise perfect weekend trip.  Hopefully the Derby will someday only be open to colts and also lessen their entry allowance to 14 horses.  Even though Eight Belles showed that she was as good as any colt - it wasn't worth losing her. Eight Belles, rest in peace, know that you are loved and will always remain in the hearts of all race fans.

There she was in all her splendor, the big gray magnificent filly, in the red and white silks, number 5, strutting her stuff in the paddock.  For many it was love at first sight, for me a continued love affair. She was so very regal and had a certain grace about her. Could she fulfill her destiny? Eight Belles was her name and she was about to embark on her greatest challenge.  What an incredible and exciting sport!

Yet, sadly as much as I love Horse Racing and all the excitement it brings, I find it increasingly difficult to watch these races from start to finish.  Accidents and breakdowns are part of this game, but life and death issues put so much more on the line! In Kentucky Derby 134, Saturday, we saw the filly, Eight Belles give her life in a gut wrenching ,runner up performance.  Just like memories of Barbaro and the past 2 Breeder’s Cups with George Washington and Pine Island, Saturday was a sad day.

I do acknowledge the advancement of Equine Surgical procedures and the many wonderful people committed to saving these incredible animals.  The Barbaro saga really brought this to the public forefront.  Much that is positive is taking shape in this sport.

Still, each time a horse is euthanized, my heart breaks that much more! These noble, beautiful, graceful and powerful creatures have always shown me that on earth, heaven does exist.  Yes, I am an avid Horse Racing enthusiast but what I really love is the horse. Of all sports, the heroes I embrace are horses. They give everything, so pure and innocent, with no hidden agenda or thought of tomorrow.  I followed Eight Belles quite closely this year, reading everything I could find on this proud gray filly. She was my favorite, the horse I wanted to win the Derby. I was rooting for her every step of the way and was ecstatic with her second place finish to Big Brown. Shortly after her crossing the finish line, and breaking down, I thought of her lying on the track, frightened, confused. Fortunately, Euthanasia was quick! Question after question, heartbreak, tears and sadness engulfed me.  What  a price to pay for giving so much of herself?

What now? I will move on and in time chose a new favorite. My hope is that breakdowns and injuries become less prevalent and that the strides the industry is making start hitting pay dirt. I will keep alert to ways the public can help, and continue to donate and support horse charities. I do however, expect to be saddened again. I will watch these races with the realization that death is just a footprint away. It is the harsh reality of this sport and the price you pay for being a fan of this game. The horse can only hope for a healthy, successful race career so that retirement or breeding are options.  Just as Eight Belles gave so much, I too will give my heart to other horses .

Finally, I just wanted to tell you Eight Belles, you looked absolutely stunning in the Derby. Thanks for being my hero! Rest in peace.

Like many racing fans and owners I watched Big Brown power to the finish line, and thought we have a horse destined be a Triple Crown winner. I watched

Eight Belles cross second and thought how much heart she had, what a beautiful,

game filly. This feeling of exhilaration was short lived, as catastrophe

unfolded. The day, like so many classic races before will forever be shrouded in sadness.

We focus on synthetic surfaces, on steroid use, everything but the truth.  

Perhaps we have bred our blood lines too perfectly, perhaps its time for the

Jockey club to meet with breeders and strengthen the legs of our horses, by

introducing a hardier breed into the thoroughbred lines. I for one would gladly

sacrifice a second or two of speed for less injuries, less sadness.

Secondly, perhaps we need to consider starting our horses one year later.  

Giving their skeletal system one more year to strengthen could only help.

These catastrophic breakdowns, drive new fans away from the sport we love. It even illicites doubts as to my own love of the sport. My deepest heartfelt regrets are extended to the connections of Eight Belles, she gave her live for two minutes of our entertainment; but has really left us a lifetime of mourning for so many fallen athletes. We owe it to our horses to find a remedy, whatever that might be.

I have been following horseracing since 1971 and have seen every triple crown and championship race on television since then. After viewing Saturday's Kentucky Derby I couldn't help but to feel sickened at the sight of Eight Belles lying on the track afterward.  It seems that every couple of broadcasted races a horse gets killed. George Washington in the Breeder's Cup as well as the many before him and now Eight Belles in the derby. I don't plan on watching the Preakness or Belmont because I doubt my stomach will be up to it.

I'm also a horse owner and ride hunters & jumpers, so I'm familiar with leg injuries. This filly was clearly injured coming out of the final turn,  you can see her bobble and shorten stride then the jockey hits her with the whip after that, it's so obvious. I was surprised she made it to the finish line. Take a look at Eight Belles stride coming through the stretch, she appears to be hopping on her front legs. In other words, both of her front legs look as though they are hitting the ground together. A horse does not run in full stride with both front legs hitting the ground at the same time.  You can tell she is either completely exhausted, injured or both. That's the last horse race I'll ever watch.

The beginning of a new racing season....and the gods exacted their pound of flesh early on.

I know that I will hear many times over in the next few days that this is a barbaric sport...that we force these animals to run, and that they will never watch it again. My answers remain the same as they have for years.  We watch it because we are awestruck by the beauty and the pageantry..and the knowlege that these magnificent creatures have this deeply embedded in their souls. They are born to run...and nothing can take that out of them.  It's what drives them, from the moment that they are born..their "Raison D'Etre"...reason for being. A thoroughbred's legs may break...but their hearts cannot. We saw that clearly illustrated yesterday.  And, yes...you WILL watch it again. If the love of the Sport of Kings is in your heart, you will be compelled to. If it isn't, then pick up your toys and go on home.

 Thank you Ed McNamara, our local news reporter for your great coverage.  Thanks to Big Brown for running a great race...and thanks most of all to the filly who slammed it home to all of us. She did her owners, trainer, jockey, all the rest of us,as well as herself proud. She showed us the reason to keep coming back to the track.

  Goodbye, Eight Belles... magnificent job....well done!!

As a long-time fan of thoroughbred horse racing , I was thrilled to see that racing at Churchill Downs for the day of the Derby was going to be a successful day, with all jockeys and horses having a safe trip, but then absolute and unexplainable tragedy occurred.

I could not believe what I was seeing on the television screen.  As a write this letter, tears are in my eyes.  I don’t know Mr. Larry Jones, I never met Eight Belles, or know her connections, but my heart weeps for all of them, and especially for Eight Belles.  

Once again, the eyes are on the sport of thoroughbred racing to change their ways, to make things better.  Everyone keeps mentioning the synthetic surfaces as the save all for this sport.  Maybe the change to a synthetic surface will provide some benefit and provide relief from such horrific and senseless tragedies like this from occurring, but I am not optimistic that will be the case.

In my heart, I don’t believe polytrack, cushion track, or any of the synthetic surfaces are the answer.  Significant changes need to occur in the sport of thoroughbred racing and now:

1. The overall philosophy of the sport needs to change.  The sport has become too much like a business, with the main piece, a majestic living animal, the horse, paying the price much too often

2. The medication rules, regulations, and penalties need to be developed, standardized, communicated, and strictly enforced, with tough penalties, financial and other.

3. The breeding program needs to change: less horses being bred and horses bred for stamina, not just speed.  Owners and breeders need to assume responsibility of the horses when the racing days are over.

4. The training and racing regiment and asking these horses to go so fast so young, needs to change.  The racing programs need to offer more races that are longer.

5. The claiming game needs to change so that horses that should not be racing at all are not racing.

I am sure tragedies will still continue, but at the moment there are just too many catastrophic injuries occurring too often.  It is becoming more and more difficult to be a supporter of this sport.  

PETA needs to stay out of situations they know nothing about.  Attempts by them to suspend Eight Belles jockey, Gabriel Saez, and revoke the $400,000 second-prize money that this gallant filly earned in the Kentucky Derby, because she was "doubtlessly injured before the finish of the race" are quite possibly the most ridiculuos statements I have ever heard in my life.  I'm glad that the racing people that actually would make these decisions have more sense.  However, I'm deeply concerned that casual fans are going to be turned against the Fox Hill Farm team by these ignorant words.  Classier horsemen than those that make up the FHF team cannot be found anywhere.  To make this already very difficult time for them harder by issuing such uneducated accusations is sick and wrong.  Anyone with sense at all can see that Eight Belles hit the wire full of run, with a completely normal stride.  You can see the instance she breaks stride, a full quarter mile after the wire, a SINGLE stride before she falls.  She galloped out with her ears pricked.  Horses for Dummies describes a horse with pricked ears as "happy and/or interested."  Horses with broken ankles are not happy or interested, nor do they make it a full quarter mile before falling.  She was doubtlessly not injured untilt the second before she fell, and PETA are doubtlessly idiots.

The 2008 Kentucky Derby at Churchill Downs delivered a weather-perfect day to the second largest crowd ever to fill the stands for the “Run for the Roses” as we again hope that, after 30 years of waiting, the racing gods will smile on one truly gifted colt or filly and give us our 12th winner of the Triple Crown.

The good news? Big Brown actually lived up to his favored status with an explosive run, carrying him to an impressive victory.

We thought the racing gods HAD actually smiled, and that that same smile extended to a beautiful, elegant filly outrunning 18 other colts to come in second.

Then it happened. The Bad.

A stumble perhaps? A misstep maybe. Most likely, exhausted legs that were just too weary to carry her one more stride. She was down, never to rise again. She, quite literally, “...didn’t have a leg to stand on.”

Racing fans will remember another catastrophically-injured filly named Pine Island and her “Go For Wand” tumble when the Breeders’ Cup was last at Churchill Downs. Another filly was injured in that same race. Both of them stood there in agony for far too long, especially the second filly, as they, their trainers and the vets waited for the Kimzey Horse Ambulances to navigate through the crowds.

To be injured as was Eight Belles is just plain ugly...just plain bad.  But Churchill did a better job this time. They learned from their mistake. Not one, but TWO ambulances rolled up and surrounded her immediately, even as it was being determined that she could not be saved. The means and the manpower were there in quick time this time, keeping the filly from a lengthy period of suffering.

The first Saturday in this May could not have been more beautiful. The race could not have been more beautifully run. Big Brown showed himself the true favorite with a triumphant run. But so did a filly named Eight Belles. She was a champion before the race, and she was a champion after the race.

But she died in the effort. The only consolation, the only “better,” was that this time, Churchill Downs did not fail her.

Run with the Angels, Eight Belles. And Rest in Peace.

As tragic as the death of Eight Belles was, maybe her death and the public outcry across the country will finally be a wake up call to the thoroughbred breeding industry.  Even the likes of the Jim Rome Show on ESPN tonight were saying what I have for years:  They only breed for speed and have created a weaker breed.  And the argument about there being more tracks and more races to fill today doesn't apply.  The industry can "put their finger in the dike" with these synthetic tracks, but they're ignoring the real problem.

In the good old days of racing, horses ran more, and they raced longer.  Seabiscuit, crooked legs and all, raced thirty-five times as a two-year old and raced until he was seven.  Phar Lap was run several times A WEEK.  Today on Good Morning, America, Jeanine Edwards said a horse cannot run on a fractured leg.  In the 1958 Belmont Stakes, Tim Tam fractured a sesamoid at the quarter pole, finished in second place well ahead of the field, and went on to a career at stud.  All this is not just my opinion.  It's there in the black and white of Past Performance charts.

We are hearing about breakdowns more than ever - that's the world of media invasion we live in.  They flock to sensational stories like vultures over a dying animal.  Horse racing is dying right now, and the vultures are circling.  I hope to God the industry leaders will wake up and do the right thing.

She was beautiful, and gifted.  She had every right to run the derby, and was my personal choice for second. She was another super filly.  What happened is sad, and opens eyes, but she had every right to run. No one is at fault, but perhaps we can learn from this disaster.  My best to her owner and trainer.  

I've been into racing since I was 3 years old and I made my first trip to the track with my family.  That's a longer time ago than I care to admit.  The Kentucky Derby, the Breeder's Cup -- these were leading items on my "things to do in my lifetime list."  Not anymore.  For a sport trying to revive its failing fortunes, having your marquee events turn into spectacles of animal death and dismemberment is probably not the way to go.  And all of the memory walls and romanticizing of the death of a gallant creature like Eight Belles does nothing.  

 Just want to let Rick, Larry, & all of the other people who loved & cared for Eight Belles, how truly sorry I am for their tragic loss. I was really pulling for her to win the Derby. She ran a awesome race & she didn't look to me like she was straining at all. She seemed to be running with ease, like she was enjoying the run. I have followed Rick's horses for awhile & I really believe if there had been any chance for her to pull through he would have done whatever he could for her. I have always been impressed with the care and love he has shown all his horses. Thanks for showing the world that there are owners out there who really love & care about these horses.

 I quess, like everyone else, I ask myself where or what is the problem. Personally I believe its in the genetics. Why is it that the great ones that were run in the 20's,30's,40's & 50's were able to last so long at the track & they were run hard & often. I always thought it was be so thrilling to own & race thoroughbreds, but I think the emotional toll would be to much!

Once we get by the hurt, let's take a good hard look at the breeding practices in the U.S.  Speed does come at a price and is this price too high?  With documentation of bone size becoming smaller and weaker, shouldn't we take a look at expanding the gene pool and once again breed horses for soundness and not just speed.

Eight Belles was a magnigicent animal and should be remembered as that, but her legacy could be the watermark to a brighter future for the breed.

I never knew Eight Bells. But I watched a lot of her races on TV. What a beautiful filly she was. I was shocked when she went down. I cried when they gave the bad news. But I will remember what a wonderful and beautiful filly she was.

Rest in peace beautiful girl.

I was happy that Big Brown won the Derby. I was proud of Eight Belles's effort. When the camara switched over to her lying on the track motionless I knew her fate was seeled. May she rest in peace and run forever with the greats. We will never forget you grey beauty.

I've followed this beautiful filly since she broke her maiden at deleware and ever since then i've had the highest expectations of her. She delivered every time she hit the track and by the way she moved you could tell she loved nothing more than running that oval whether in the morning or afternoons.My heart goes out to all those who got to spend time around her and got to know her personality,likes and dislikes. To larry jones' family, you guys took care of her better than anyone could have imagined and did right by her every step of the way.I'm positive the porters miss this great one and I can only hope her memory lives on forever. To gabby Saez, Keep your head up, keep riding hard, and always remember that everyone points a finger looking for someone to blame. You are not in any way reponsible, and i wish people out there could understand the pain and agony you must be going through as well. To the filly I never had the pleasure of meeting but stole my heart from day one. Eight Belles you were a great friend, companion, daughter and sister. You will forever be remembered by this fan as a great horse, one whom god had a different plan for. We miss you Eight Belles.

TAPS

My heart aches and the tears flow.  I'm so sorry for your loss.  She was a special filly.

What great things can be said about Eight Belles that hasn't been said already? You gave us your all, your life, and I'll never forget seeing you fly down the stretch, 18 boys behind n your wake. Run in peace. My heart goes out to Gabe Saez, Larry Jones, and everyone who was connected with Eight Belles. It was no ones fault, and they shouldn't be treated as such. I'm truly sorry.

For me, EIGHT BELLES was the best horse in the Kentucky Derby, bar none.  The running of the race saw her boxed in and stopped more than once when she finally got a clear shot she took of after Big Brown like a rocket, he had the first jump.  With a clear run they would have been head and head.  We know she was tough, how would he have handled being looked in the eye?  My deepest sympathy to all concerned with this GREAT CHAMPION, you made the right decision to give her the chance she was bred for and pay no mind to the idiotic criticism from people who have no understanding of racing and the rapport, love and mutual respect shared between horse, trainer and most owners.  This performance following her other prior victories makes her in my book HORSE OF THE YEAR 2008.  

The Kentucky sky will forever shine a little brighter because her star has joined the Ages....and while we are poorer from this great loss, we are richer for having known her in the first place. Run freely on in the Light, gallant darling girl. We will never forget your noble heart.

"I am fire and air, my other elements I give to baser life."

Antony & Cleopatra.  

TO LIVE IN THE HEARTS OF THE ONES WE LEAVE BEHIND, IS TO NEVER DIE.

REST IN PEACE EIGHT BELLES

3 Year old fillies are not physically mature enough to run with colts in the 20 horse free for all the derby has become.

First of all, My heart goes out to the Jockey, Trainer and Owners of eight belles.

Most of all ( PETA) are the Morons of the world, they know absolutely nothing about the sports and are trouble makers. They need to go away and get a life!!.  

I saw the race on T.V. I said this cannot be happening again. My wife and I go to the Preakness every year. I was there for the Barbaro race at the Preakness it happened right in front of us. Its not a good thing to see. I cant imagine what the owners of Eight Belles are going through.

But, I have to agree with most comments above and the horses of old ran there butts off for many years before stud duty. Because they where breed the proper way.

The industry needs to take a step back in time and rebuild for the future and forget about speed.

The problem I see is everyone is trying to recreate (Ruffian). what they dont understand is Ruffian was a natural who kicked the crap out of every horse in her way. Ruffian was not a robot built on drugs & medication.

She was a true champion, Lets bring the true champions back to the race tracks.

you did such an amazing job, we're all so proud of you.  RIP beautiful.

tell Barbaro I miss him.

Very sad about the filly. I do agree these horses shouldn't compete until they are at least 3 years old. I also think the Reiners, Western Pleasure riders, etc. shouldn't be competing horses at 2 either. BTW, 2 eventing horses were euthanized at the Rolex 3-day event this last weekend. As for PETA, they frighten me with their ignorance of horse behavior. Those whips don't even have lashes and are used for steering since the jockeys don't have their legs on the horse's sides. Horses move away from pressure, and reins are fairly inadequate for accurately steering a running horse in traffic. If the whips were upsetting those horses, they'd easily buck their tiny little riders off instead of running. PETA could find better causes... like the horses sent to slaughter.

My condolences to Larry Jones and his crew. Eight Belles was a wonderful filly and I know they loved her deeply. I viewed the movie First Saturday In May which featured him and his family and there is no doubt in my mind that Larry feels that these horses are part of his extended family.The fact that he would get up on her in the morning to gallop her and bond with her, surely made it even harder to deal with.

Larry if there is a heaven; she will be waiting for you there.

My heart goes out to all those in connection with Eight Belles.  Her death is one of grace and beauty and should be remembered as such.  I believe that these horses genuinely love racing and so it should be seen as her dying with love.  I am an animal lover as well as feel a deep connection to these thoroughbreds. They put their hearts and souls into that track and should be honored as such. There is no one to blame for this tragedy and should be something that unites us with our love of these magnificant beasts and how much joy and happiness they provide for us. I take solice in knowing that Eight Belles has joined the greats as ruffian, pine island, barbaro and all of the hundreds of horses that have lost their lives on the track, they are now free and we must honor the beauty in that.

I was asked to comment on the breakdown of Eight Belles at work on Sat.My co-workers can't spell racehorse,but they asked me because I'm an old racetracker(groom,trainer,owner).My comments were as follows "You hope when you breed and train racehorses that you can bring out all the talent and heart that they have.She layed her body down and gave it everything she had" I wish I had owned or trained a horse with one tenth of the heart she showed that day.Please remember her in that light And to her connections,you were so lucky to have known her.

Eight Belles , what can be said , you made a good account of yourself , bravo to you. You are now resting with all the other great horse's from racing past.

You must of been some kind of filly

for your owners to start running you in September of your second year and run you every month thereafter. Maybe it was all that wear and tear that finally caught up with you in the Derby, your tenth and final race. May you now Rest In Peace , unfortunately , it took someone superior to realize , enough is enough, time to come home, you've given enough of yourself on planet earth. There are greener pastures where you are now. RIP

it hurts to see things like that happen. Eight Belles had A LOT of heart. It isn't the jockey, trainer, owner, or connections fault. people are blaming the jockey and the race. she gave no indication of being hurt.

It was not the race, that's for sure. Everyone can agree with me that she was catching Big Brown effortlessly, ears pricked and all.

Humane Society and all those people should go and hound the lower ranks who drug their horses to run. These big time people don't need drugs to make a horse good. they can BUY a good horse that can win.

My Heart goes to Gabe and Jones and all of Eight Belles' connections.

Beautiful Belles, you had an amazing spirit. These are the times that make it tough to be a race fan. You crossed the wire ahead of the best three year old colts in the country with your ears up, begging to go farther...you proved that you belonged in the toughest race there is, and that you loved every second of it. I don't know why this had to happen to you, but I know that somewhere, somehow you're still running with your ears up.

Rest in peace, darling.

Eight Belles, your spirit is free, you were a very strong girl..  I'm so sad to know your life was cut so short..  you were worth so much more than that.  I hope the memory of you will bring changes to the horse racing industry and more safety to future racehorses.

Eight Belles (like Ruffian, Go For Wand, Barbaro, etc.) are the truly great horses.  They have so much will to win that they run harder and faster than the usual 'joes'.  Unfortunately for racing, the great ones are the ones that the non-racing world get a chance to see, and then scream foul.  In one article, it was stated that Eight Belles was put down to save the viewers and the crowd from their agony.  Belle' pain and chance of survival were all that were considered, and humanely, she was put down.  I have lived and loved Thoroughbred racing my whole life, and will continue as long as there is a breath in my body.  The connections with Belle did what was right for her.  A video click prior to the Derby showed Mr. Jones on Belle breazing, and he had trouble getting her to pull up.  Hugs to all connections.  And to those of you who continue to condemn racing... get educated.

Eight Belles went out the way she whould of wanted to. Yes to early but she gave her life to show the world just what kind of heart she had. There are tragities in every sport, that's what brings people closer to the game and let's people truly understand how remarkable she was. All I can say to Eight Belles, is thank you for making me fall in love with you and the greatest sport in the world. I can't wait to see you again some day.

I have shed tears while reading all the comments extolling Eight Belles' heart and talent, and the calls for changes in breeding and racing, and I want to add my voice to both.  

We all know that these equine athletes' fragile legs too often don't support their muscularity and their competitive spirits.  We know that the sight of magnificent animals suffering gruesome injuries at showcase events will never translate to the increased fan base needed to sustain the sport.

With changes, I think racing will survive, as it has survived the high-profile tragedies of Ruffian, Go for Wand and Barbaro.  These shining stars are gone, and the fleet, smoky heroine Eight Belles has joined them.  I and all fans of the Thoroughbred call on the breeding-racing complex to work together to promote not only record auction prices, the growth of betting handle and racing's "biggest days," but most importantly equine health and welfare.  

The Run for the Roses, with its tradition and glamour, represents the dreams of all who are connected to these charismatic animals.  At this year's renewal, a dream and a life ended up in the dirt. The image is disturbing and I want to forget it, but I can't.  RIP, Eight Belles.

Eight Belles was a great filly who will be missed!  She gave one great final race for us to remember her by!  Quit with all the whining about things that aren't directly related to REMEMBERING this great filly!  This isn't the time nor the place for it!

To Eight Belles' connections, my thoughts & prayers are with you during this difficult time!

I'm going to say it one more time, this filly was loved and well taken care of.  Larry Jones is a good trainer and Gabriel Saez is not at fault.  None of these people deserve any blame whatsoever.  

Belles you were a beautiful, beautiful girl in mind, spirit and body.  May your death not be in vain.  Let it be the catalyst that finally forces horse racing to take a long, hard look at what has become and make the changes it needs to bring it back to glory.

All the slots in the world will not save thoroughbred racing.  Only the love of horses and racing and right now it's very hard to love knowing your heart may very well be broken over and over.  

RIP sweet girl...

Though I'm no expert in the world of racing, I do know that thoroughbreds are one of the lightest boned breeds out there.  Take a look at other breeds that compete - jumpers, hunters, cross-country, rodeo horse's - all of them have heavier boned legs.  It's like asking a ballerina to run a marathon over a course track.  Her legs are trained to dance not climb mountains.

Because these horses are started out under the age of two to train to race and then are considered to old to race after 4, the animals are raced as babies....(18-mos -3 yrs)

Unfortunately every individual who participates in this sport in anyway, shape or form condones this.  

After much reading I've come to realize only the best horses in racing are the ones older than 5...

Unfortunately we only acknowledge the juveniles as being the greatest.

Don't get me wrong there will always be those that stand out, but they are the exceptions.

Eight Belles' breakdown was a freak accident and I'm happy to note that before she's cremated a thorough exam is being done.

The best way to combat this is to change the thought process on breeding....Do we want fast horses or living horses?

We All Play A Part!

Thanks All

Ok, this is a memory wall..not a place to USE this poor sweet filly's tragedy to bash on horse racing.  Yes, there are many problems that need addressing but please, have some respect.

My heart goes out to all of her connections...

Rest in Peach beautiful girl....run free at the Rainbow Bridge! <3 Will never forget you!

I too was rooting for Eight Belles against the boys and was screaming in joy that she was second to Big Brown in the Derby.  It broke my heart to see her lying in track helpless.  This was supposed to be the best Derby in last 20 years and now it will be overshadowed by the tragic unforunate death of a great filly.  After reviewing the comments above, I do believe that they should not allow horses to race until they are at least 4 years of age when their bones are more fully devolped.  There should be more research into equine medical treatment to help critically injured horses.  If a dog breaks both of its legs, we do not immediately put it to sleep.  I will still be a fan of horseracing because freak accidents do happen and for all the horses that are active in racing, there is just a very small percentage that this happens to.  

Eight Belles will be remembered as one of the greatest fillies of all horseracing!

Has anyone looked at the loss of colts in this attitude? is it just fillies?  Should we wait a little longer for maturity? Is it the genetics have we looked at all of the aspects such a terrible loss for everyone concerned my sincerest sympathies to the whole industry upon the loss of thiss heroic animal.

I also witnessed this tragedy at the kentuck derby.  I question myself everyday as to why i keep wathcing.   but seeing smarty jones up close at three chimney's farm keeps me hooked.  My heart goes out to Eight Belles and her conections.  I would be overcome with grief if this had happened to one of my horses.  Rest in Peace great Filly!!!!  You will always be remembered by me for your greastness, not your trageic ending.... anna seals

oops, that would be Rest in Peace sweetheart!

Gate to wire, Eight Belles ran the race of her life. Sadly, her life ended with the cheers for that peformance still filling her ears. Though death came far too early for the brilliant filly, a legacy  was born from her tragedy -- a champion who laid down her life stretching her natural talents to their ultimate limits. Though one finished in front of her, she earned a measure of respect perhaps greater than the one who banked the winner's share.  To her trainer, owner and rider who had insight into her abilities, which most fans saw only for a span of 2:01 4/5, thank you for that glimpse of greatness we would not have otherwise experienced. Your courage and sporting character are a treasure to the game.            

very sorry to all those connected with her, but she will live on forever in Derby folklore as the brave filly who finshed to the undefeated Triple Crown winner BIG BROWN, may she rest in peace.........

It was a terrible tragedy, and I know all of her connections feel devastated by the loss.  Unfortunately, we have a sector of the public, the animal rights mob, who want to exploit this in order to ban horse racing and all other animal sports to further their insane agenda of no domestication of animals because of "ethical" reasons.  They are despicable and need to be outed.  Will the racing industry challenge these liars head-on?

Belle was my first pick, BB my second. Though she technically finished second on paper, Belle was a winner. Her death has sickened me, brought me to tears. I'm still crying. She was a filly for the ages.

RIP Belle. I love you, and I miss you.

As horse owners we do not ride yearlings but many race horses are started before their 2nd birthday.  That does not give ample time for the bones to mature and develop properly.

My heart goes out to her owners and the people that loved her. Maybe she can force change in an industry.

In loving memory let us make this change!!!

You are what this sport is about and you old girl, all heart & class.

We will tell our grandchildren about the unbelivable effort saturday! And you EIGHT BELLES will live forever a champion....

Big Brown a monster horse,Eight Belles a masterful filly,i'm proud of her!!!.From Kentucky,America,to Andalusia,Spain,the usque ad coelos et usque ad inferos magic of the Derby has touched my heart.Long life to the sport of the kings!!!

Such a tragedy. Eight Belles was destined for greatness, a Breeders Cup entry to be sure.  Unfortunately she will now be remembered by most as the filly that broke down at the Kentucky Derby. But to those who follow racing, she was much more than that, and her memory will be cemented by the racing history she achieved in her short career.  The industry needs to take a hard look at itself and do what is necessary to stop these catastrophic events. Stop the excuses -- the world is watching.

It is greater to have loved and lost than never to have loved at all. Thank you Eight Belles, Barbaro, Pine Island, Go for Wand, Ruffian, etc, and my own personal lost love that none of you have ever heard of, Secret Defense, for that chance to love.

Eight Belles will be remembered, a winner and champion, she did "run the race of her life" quite eloquently I might say.....she now roams with Barbaro and others before her......They will not be forgotten....but in our hearts.

I have been devistated since the moment I saw her laying on the track Saturday on TV. This filly was destined for greatness and I makes my heart ache. I can only hope that she is in heaven running with Barbaro, Ruffian, Three Degrees and all the other beauties. God bless her and her connections. Rest well, beautiful girl.

To the connections of Eight Belles I offer a prayer of peace and solace.  You were given a wonderful gift in Eight Belles and she returned that gift one hundred fold.  I thank you for sharing her with us.  

THIS IS A TERRIBLE TRAGEDY, I DID NOT WATCH IT BECAUSE OF WHAT HAPPEND TO BARBARO, I JUST CAN'T HANDLE SEEING A ANIMAL IN PAIN. MY HEART GOES OUT TO ALL THAT WERE CONNECTED TO EIGHT BELLES, SHE WAS A BEAUTIFUL, BEAUTIFUL GIRL, HER LIFE WAS CUT WAY TOO SHORT, I WISH THEY WOULD WAIT TILL THESE HORSES ARE OLDER BEFORE THEY START RACING THEM. REST IN PEACE EIGHT BELLES, YOU WILL NEVER BE FORGOTTEN.

Eight Belles - determination, talent, heart, blessed with everything that makes a horse a champion.  

Beautiful Belle....

We will miss your beauty and free spirit so much but know that your are up there running and challenging the very best right now. Give all those who passed before you our love and never forget what a true champion you are...

Taken from the movie Dreamer, the following quote seems only fitting for such a beautfiul filly....I hope I can one day meet you at the Bridge and do just that!

You are a great champion. When you ran the ground shook. The sky opened & mere mortals parted. Parted the way to victory. Where you will meet me in the winner's circle, & I will lay a blanket of flowers on your back.

Fly like the wind beautiful one...you may be gone but you'll NEVER be forgotten.

What a bittersweet Derby it was.  Everyone in Louisville was pulling for Big Brown, the UPS hub being here.  Seeing him thunder across that finish line was spectacular, only to be followed by the heart sickening spectacle of watching Eight Belles fall to the ground after such a harrowing run right behind Big Brown.  Like so many before ... she gave it her all.

I love horse racing, but I love horses more, and as the trainer so aptly put it, this happened for a reason, and perhaps that reason is change!

Here's to a lovely horse with the heart of a champion.

I don't know much about horse racing, just love to watch these beautiful animals. I always choose my horse, not by standings, but just by the one I like best out of all of them. I chose Eight Belles in the Kentucky Derby, I can't say why it was just a feeling when I saw her. She was a beautiful animal and she definately had a lot of heart. I am so sorry for your loss.

First Barbaro who stole our hearts with his courage, then George Washington--who had NO business in that race or on that surface, now Eight Belles.

There are a hundred reasons why she broke down. Surface, inbreeding, weary legs, who knows.

None of it matters. Peta has no business pointing fingers, it won't bring her back.

To the Jones camp, I am heartsick for your loss.  I know what it's like to see that empty stall in your barn.  

Hang in there and remember what joy that girl brought you!

Our hearts ache over the Eight Belles tragedy.  She ran her heart out and fought until the finish.  She's a true champion and we'll never forget her valiant effort.

God Bless You, Eight Belles & Thank You!!

I was rooting for Eight Belles and she was one of my picks. She displayed the highest virtues possessed by a Thoroughbred: courage, perserverance, and an intense will to compete. She was for me an equine heroine. I shall miss her dearly, and will always love her.

Rest in peace, lovely lady. You have taken your place with the racing immortals.

The loss of Eight Belles on Saturday was about as tragic as it gets...I couldn't help but be reminded of another filly, who years before had impressed me so with her athletic ability that I remember her still to this day--Ruffian.

Condolences to her owners and to all in her barn.

While there may not be an obvious reason for why this happened, perhaps it can help to fuel the argument for starting colts (and fillies) later to allow them to develop further and to race with less possibility of injury...If there was ever a time for change in the Thoroughbred racing world, please let this be it!

We watch it because we are awestruck by the beauty and the pageantry..and the knowledge that these magnificent creatures have this deeply embedded in their souls. They are born to run...and nothing can take that out of them.  It's what drives them, from the moment that they are born..their "Raison D'Etre"...reason for being."

I disagree, Pam F.  Yes, it feels good to them to run because they're given the most nutritional food and exercised to the point where they're jumping out of their skin and have to let it out somehow, but they wouldn't feel that way if they weren't deliberately put in that position. When they're put out to pasture for the 20-25 years of their life that they're not running, they adjust just fine.

Yes, some will battle it out on the track and really want to win, but they wouldn't know anything about racing and wouldn't miss it if they weren't introduced to it by people who's make goal is to make a ton of money off of them.  

I've loved horses and racing since I was little, and even fulfilled a dream and worked on a track for awhile.  

But I'm starting to dread watching races anymore.  It should be fun, not worrisome.

When you can't even enjoy watching the Kentucky Derby anymore, something needs to change.

This was my 51st Derby and by far, the saddest Derby I've ever seen.  Every year I wish for the horses to get around the oval in one piece and return safely to their barns.  This year, one stall was empty.  Eight Belles tried her heart out and gave her heart to heaven a few minutes later.  We have lost another beloved horse, but Rainbow Bridge has gained a sweetheart.  I'm so sorry she won't be around to thrill us any longer.  I hope Big Brown wins the Triple Crown.  With his red, white and blue silks, America needs a boost right about now.

Eight Belles was my favorite, and she ran a GREAT race. My heart broke for her when I saw her down and heard what had happened. She was a beauty and a Great Filly.