BloodHorse.com

Risen Star, Robert B. Lewis Analysis

30 Comments

Risen Star - Fair Grounds

I expected to see many of the same horses from the Lecomte in here (there are four), but didn't expect to see a total of 13 entered. It has made for a very good, but challenging betting race. We'll find out a lot about several so-called Derby contenders after this one is over.

If you watched That Handicapping Show you will know that I like Indygo Mountain in this spot. Throw out his Lecomte, where he was coming off two bruised feet, had missed two works and drew the outside post. To make matters worse he hit the gate at the start and had no chance. He has been healthy and training better since that time and draws post 2. Bret Calhoun says he has matured a lot in the past month and his stride has improved. I think Theriot will have him near the lead and will be looking for a big stretch run.

Many will settle on the two probable favorites - Giant Oak and Friesan Fire - and there is not much reason to dislike either. Friesan Fire finally lived up to Larry Jones' billing in his Lecomte win and seems to be a more focused colt with the addition of blinkers. I did not like his last work on Feb. 2, however, and think Indygo Mountain will turn the tables. I'm also going against Jones' other horse, It Happened Again. He really had no excuse in the Sugar Bowl at Fair Grounds two race ago, which could mean he isn't crazy about the track. He will also be stretching out for the first time.

Nobody has been training better than Giant Oak, who makes his 3-year-old debut. Big bucks were offered for this colt, but the owner turned it down - a sign that he is the real deal. He will be coming from off the pace under Edgar Prado and many are expecting him to pick up all the pieces. The major negative on Giant Oak is that he has been off for more than two months. He may very well win this thing, but I usually take a stand against favorites when coming off lengthy layoffs. I think he needs a race and his best effort will come in the Louisiana Derby.

Steve Asmussen, who won this race last year with Pyro, has entered three - Uno Mas, Dumar and Soul Warrior. Leave his horses out of exotics at your own risk. Uno Mas is likely to improve after a wide trip in Lecomte and don't forget that he beat Friesan Fire here two starts back going a mile. Dumar and Soul Warrior broke their maidens over this track last out, both going long. I prefer Dumar here since Bridgmohan stays on and he has a better post, but I'll use both underneath.

I still like Au Moon, but not in this spot.  Drawing the 13 post is probably too much to overcome.

The Pick: My win money will be on Indygo Mountain and I'll use him in an exacta box with all three Asmussen horses (2/5,8,10). For trifectas, I'll include Friesan Fire and Giant Oak.

Robert. B Lewis - Santa Anita

Another good betting race, especially if you think the probable favorites are vulnerable, which I do. Pioneerof the Nile comes off a nose victory over I Want Revenge in the CashCall, and those two will likely be the post time choices. If Pioneerof the Nile handles these, he shoots right to the top of the West Coast Derby contenders. I Want Revenge, who adds blinkers for the first time, has been working very well leading up to this race and should be in contention. I think both will be sharp, but prefer the horse that both of them beat in the CashCall, Bittel Road.

This is a make-or-break race for Bittel Road, who finished fourth in the CashCall while making his first start off turf and breaking from unenviable post 10. He was also hung wide on both turns under Mike Smith. I expect him to improve in his second try, especially since Pletcher flies Johnny V. in for the mount. He broke his maiden and also won the Bourbon Stakes at this distance and draws the inside, which means he'll probably be in a good spot for a late run. A $340,000 yearling, I can't help but think we haven't seen the best of this colt just yet.

Other possibilities here are Shafted and Brother Keith. Both of them are head-scratchers at this point. Shafted won his allowance race back on Jan. 2 at this distance after making his first two starts in Canada. But this is a big step up in class and I'm not yet sure what he's made of. I'm also not sure what to think about Brother Keith after he was rank and blew the first turn in the San Rafael. There is no doubt he'll improve from that one, but will it be good enough to tackle these? Probably not.

The Pick: I prefer Bittel Road here, but don't see any way of leaving Pioneerof the Nile and I Want Revenge off exacta tickets. I'll box a 1/2,4 exacta.

Finally, in the Whirlaway from Aqueduct, Haynesfield is the one to beat but I'll take a shot with a Philly Park shipper, Hehasnosay, who came from the clouds to win a two-turn allowance race in December for Steve Klesaris.

Be sure to click on the Risen Star and Robert B. Lewis links for Ultimate PPs courtesy of Brisnet.com.

Good luck to everyone this weekend. Let me know who you like.

30 Comments:

Hi Jason:

Like some of your selctions,but I like Pioneer of the Nile to win.

MIKE RELVA 06 Feb 2009 2:06 PM

I have to go with Indygo Mountain

and maybe Freisan Fire. I'm hoping Bret has Indygo right and he's fixed that gate banging.

The Lewis?  Bittel Road and Pioneer of The Nile but I'm ambivalent about what any of these guys will add to the Derby picture.

Bradgm 06 Feb 2009 2:07 PM

Let me correct that. I'm not sure what any of those coming out of the Robert B. Lewis will add to the Derby picture.

I think the Derby future lies in Arkansas or the East coast this year. Only Stardom Bound peaks my interest here on the left coast.

Bradgm 06 Feb 2009 2:10 PM

I like I Want Revenge, however my pick for the Derby, is Jerry Hollendorfer colt, Chocolate Candy. Hollendorfer is way over due to win a Derby and should have won it in 98 with Event Of the Year who was hurt a week before the Derby.

Johnny - Dallas 06 Feb 2009 3:00 PM

Jason I think you are 100% correct.  Indygo should be much the best in here.  Giant Oak and FF are pretenders in my book.  Indygo wins for fun.  The Robert B Lewis in California is in California so does it really matter ?

Draynay 06 Feb 2009 4:18 PM

What's the big idea of picking both my horses :)?

Steve Haskin 06 Feb 2009 4:34 PM

Hey Steve: Saw your latest column where you wrote about Indygo and Bittel Road but didnt know you liked them this weekend. In fact, in this week's Derby Dozen you have Giant Oak No. 3, I Want Revenge No. 6, Pioneerof the Nile No. 8 and Friesan Fire No. 9. Seems like you have all your bases covered! :)

On another note, a lot of readers have been talking about Mr. Fantasy lately. Anything new you can tell us? I guess he's being pointed to the Gotham?

Jason Shandler 06 Feb 2009 5:04 PM

I shall just hedge my bets and cheer for Friesan Fire, Indygo Mountain, Au Moon and Vindication's son plus Giant Oak, because i love Giant's Causeway, in the Risen Star.   Then Shafted, I Want Revenge and Bittel Road in the Robert B Lewis and I am not as yet sure of the pedigrees in the Whirlaway so have no idea about that!

Will be cheering on Stardom Bound in the Las Virgenes but as i cannot actually watch any of the races that is figuratively speaking only! But will be eagerly awaiting the results to come through to see how they have all got on and will enjoy reading the reports!

Have a good weekend everyone!

God Bless

Best Wishes

Abbie

Abbie Knowles 06 Feb 2009 5:38 PM

Yeah, I could have a lot of juggling to do after this weekend. Giant Oak certainly doesnt have to win; just looking for a good race. He's such a big, long-striding horse.

I know Kiaran is pretty high onMr. Fantasy, and Buzz Chace called me all excited about him. He was the one who bought him. I love the way he runs. He overcame the outside post in his last and cruised to the lead, then ran his opponents into the ground while doing it effortlessly. I cant judge him until he faces open company.

Steve Haskin 06 Feb 2009 6:47 PM

Steve: I saw Mr. Fantasy's races on replay today, he is mighty impressive. Im going to call Terry on Monday and see what else I can find out. He might be the most impressive horse Ive seen so far. I agree he needs to face open company, but I havent seen anything in NY that can stop him.

Jason Shandler 06 Feb 2009 6:52 PM

Johnny-Dallas...You got a friend here.  Have been touting this horse.  Great connections and even better breeding.  Let's see how Pioneer of the Nile and I Want Revenge do this weekend.  You Tube the CashCall and tell me this horse was not screaming another 1/8th mile (he was last at the 1/2 mile pole and 2 lengths off of Pioneer/I want Revenge at the finish line).  He was just getting started.  It looks like Pioneer was drifting out a little (he should win easy this weekend if Baffert has worked this out).  

Householder 06 Feb 2009 6:56 PM

Jason I just watched Mr. Fantasy and his first two races... is it me or do they look a lot like Big Brown races last year?  Look for Zito to send out a flyer to test his front running style in the Gotham.

Draynay 06 Feb 2009 7:25 PM

i really think none of these horses will win the big race you are looking in the wrong spot.

moneyman 06 Feb 2009 7:58 PM

Flying Pegasus to lead them on a merry chase in the Risen Star and Brother Keith to rebound with a big effort in the Robert Lewis.

Happy hunting.

Ranagulzion 06 Feb 2009 8:03 PM

I sure liked the way I Want Revenge split horses along the rail in deep stretch in the Cash Call.  Very difficult move for such a young horse.  He looked like the real deal.  Mott/Baffert obviously has Pioneer of the Nile fit...he did get the better of the trip last time out.  These two are really hard to separate.  

Householder 07 Feb 2009 1:30 AM

I have liked POTN since I saw him race at Keeneland last Oct. As a 3yo, he has not physically matured yet and when he does, he will be a monster just like his daddy! He will be peaking for the KY Derby and surprise alot of people and show them how good he really is! The last time I picked a horse in Oct. for the derby was in 2005 with Afleet Alex and we all know what he did. No, he didn't win the Derby, but he should have. He did, however, won the last 2 TC races. Anyhow, watch out for POTN in April. I also like Patena and Hello Broadway. Good Luck to everyone!!

austinbnike 07 Feb 2009 11:05 AM

I believe that the colt that is going to serve notice -not neccessarily win- is "Shafted" these prelims are fun to watch and follow but come that first Saturday in May failing anything out of the norm happening I believe he will be there. The last time I seen a turn of foot on a colt like this his name was "Mineshaft".

TouchStone Farms 07 Feb 2009 11:53 AM

I LOVE PIONEER OF THE NILE AND THINK HE'LL WIN , HE ALWAYS PUTS OUT A BIG EFFORT. AFTER SQUARE EDDIE HES MY DERBY PICK=]

OLIVIAAA 07 Feb 2009 1:28 PM

Risen Star 2009 full of talent! Looks to be a fast pace... Au Moon needs to get position and that will get the horse up to a pretty fast pace, and may be the pace factor of this race.  I figure Giantt Oak to tuck in with Friesan Fire somewhere close behind the pace and remain there till the top of the stretch.  Those two should pass the tired pace runners and play nose to nose to the line.... watch out for Dumar charging up.. may catch and pass them both..

Giant Oak is definately the horse to bear here!

orthosrich 07 Feb 2009 2:08 PM

Saw the comment by someone who is lacking in knowledge when it comes to California racing, I think that the false idea that racing has to be back east was solved once and for all when War Admiral lost to the great, late Seabiscuit. Samual Riddle made the mistake of saying the West Coast horses could not compete with the East Coast horses, he was proven wrong! Maybe if somebody actually went to the track and placed a real bet instead of watching TV and using his credit card to bet then he could talk. My dad took me to the track and I take my son to the track and we love it. We play with real money, on real tracks with real horses. Synthetic or not our horses win, we run them fast and to win!

SanPedroPete 07 Feb 2009 3:17 PM

Feb. 7...Maiden Watch...Candy For Paseana makes his debut at Santa Anita in Maiden Special Weight.  A Candy Ride colt out of the only Paseana offsping ever conceived (Paseana's Girl).  Apparently she (Paseana) had fertility problems and was shiped back to her native Argentena. Candy Ride/Paseana offsping looks like a good combo destined for grade 1.  

Householder 07 Feb 2009 3:19 PM

Look for Nowhere to Hide to try to steal the Risen Star today. He had trouble graduating, but works have been serious. Indygo Mountain and Giant Oak appear to be the ones to fear. Shafted is getting good and could upset. I Want Revenge gets a 7 lb. weight shift over Pioneer of the Nile and may be the one to beat. Most likely to upset Stardom Bound is Navigator and Saucey Evening. Like Peace Town to run big against Haynesfield in the Whirlaway.

TonyC 07 Feb 2009 3:50 PM

THE WEST HOLDS 2 ACES!  Can another grey filly take the Santa Anita Derby from the boys?  After Stardom Bound's Las Virgenes win her connections say she can.  Pioneer of the Nile "shoots right to the top of the West Coast" contenders with his B. Lewis win.  All systems go as the Santa Anita Derby takes shape.

Householder 07 Feb 2009 7:22 PM

Wow!  My favourites were by on large on song tonight with Stardom Bound, Friesan Fire and War Echo all winning.  On investigating Pioneer of the Nile's pedigree have discoveed that not only is he an Empire Maker nd i loved him even if he did beat Funny! But he traces back to several great favourites of mine, namely, El Gran Senor, General(FR) and Brigadier Gerard!!!!!  So one to follow now and he looks lovely. Have watched the videos of "Stardom," "Friesan," and "Pioneer," and all were impressive weren't they?

Great!!!!!!!!

God Bless

Best wishes

Abbie

Abbie Knowles 07 Feb 2009 8:23 PM

Pioneer of the Nile is definately the colt I am following at this point for the Kentucky Derby. He impressed me in the CashCall Futurity and watching his performance in the Robert B. Lewis I think he showed that he can handled tough situations. He is a long striding colt which I like also. My second choice at this point goes to Friesan Fire. But things are still early out there and a mystery horse could suddenly pop up. I'm also going to keep an eye on I Want Revenge. As for Stardom Bound I really want and hope to see her in the Santa Anita Derby.

Julie L. 07 Feb 2009 9:29 PM

Two newcomers to the scene that impressed me this weekend were Papa Clem and Nowhere to Hide. Papa Clem has plenty of upside and is still learning. Like his Smart Strike pedigree and he even out worked POTN on Jan 18th. Nowhere to Hide should have learned a lot from his Risen Star try and look for big improvement next time out. These are just the type that hit the board at huge prices on Derby Day. Will watch their progress.

TonyC 08 Feb 2009 10:10 AM

pioneerof the nile giving 7 lbs to i want revenge is indication of enough improvement to lead me to believe he will be a tough animal come the 1st sat in may-don't know if he's my derby horse or not-too soon to tell-col john didn't mind dirt track at saratoga so get bogged down about west coast runners being at a disadvantage, it they'er good enough, they'll win

misting 10 Feb 2009 5:13 PM

Mr. Fantasy is a cool customer. 2 Jockeys, 2 Races, 2 Distances, 2 Wins, 2 Incredible 97 Bier Ratings, 2 relaxed finishes, he might just  become a reality, Mr. Fantasy.

Jay Rifenbary 10 Feb 2009 11:09 PM

The Gotham is shaping up to be a very key prep race with at least 3 "potentials", Mr.Fantasy, Haynesfield and Danger to Society pointing towards it. I assume we will see a few more shippers in from Florida. The winner will probably be in most top 5 rankings.  Any thoughts?

SSC 11 Feb 2009 2:21 PM

All I can say is that if Mr. Fantasy wins this one with the same ease as his other two races, he should be the front runner in the next pool...I would like to add that he would begin to look like Big Brown this time last year.

orthosrich 07 Mar 2009 10:58 AM


Resources