BloodHorse.com

Racetrack Closures Serve as a Monumental Loss to the Sport

9 Comments

By Jennifer Wirth-Ice, of The Saturday Post

Bernard Fontenelle once said, "It takes time to ruin a world, but time is all it takes." 

Perhaps, the time of ruin arrives when a single generation forgets why certain places are important.  Or possibly, the importance of the events that occurred on that ground fail to excite a culture with changing values.  It may take time to ruin a world, but if time is all it takes, the way we spend our time has an ever-increasing value toward determining what the future beholds.

In the case of racetrack closures, I wish I had spent time at those lost tracks prior to the final "Call to the Post." And, in our tracks that continue to exist today, I do.  Because, if it takes time to ruin a world, there is time to prevent the fall of it in the first place.

The question lies in how we can contribute to racing while we spend our time enjoying the sport.  I imagine the last day at Bay Meadows race track in California, where, prior to its closure, it was the longest continually-operating track in the state.  It was on this ground that Seabiscuit fought to become the two-time winner of the Bay Meadows Handicap, John Henry finished second in the same race years later, and Triple Crown Winner Citation graced the now-demolished oval near the end of his illustrious career.

In 2008, Bay Meadows was shut down after being purchased by a real estate development company.  Prior the final race, “The Last Dance Stakes,” the track bugler played “Auld Lang Syne.”  The crowd gave a standing ovation to the final string of horses to race that day, while the athletes broke from their post-parade to face the audience.  While facing the crowd, the jockeys gave a salute to the witnesses who showed up to watch the last race ever to be run on that track.  And, moments after that final salute, Bay Meadows closed for good.

When I view the six and seven figure prices paid for a single horse in a sales ring, I wonder why no one had ever thought to set up a foundation to provide funding to help save the tracks that require emergency funding, to promote the sport in general and to help fund Thoroughbred retraining and retirement.

As an owner, I would happily pay a surcharge on a sale price to ensure that the tracks can keep racing horses in the future.  Further, I would pay a nominal fee when registering a foal to help provide the necessary funding to prevent such closures.  And finally, I would happily give a percentage of my winning purse share toward a foundation that funds the promotion of Thoroughbred racing and retirement.  Because, in the final equation, it does not serve myself, nor the industry, any good to have a racehorse without a racetrack to race upon.  In the same time that leads to the closure of a track, there is time to prevent the collapse of it if funding is provided and used to promote the future of racing. 

If such a foundation had existed to save Bay Meadows, the site of Seabiscuit's two-time victory in the then-longest running race in California may not be slated to become a shopping area today.  It would be a racetrack where wonder existed as to when the next Citation, Seabiscuit, or John Henry may set foot that ground.

And, if such a foundation had existed in Illinois, Washington Park would have been rebuilt in Homewood after it was destroyed by a fire in 1977.  I would have enjoyed racing a horse in the same place where Triple Crown Winners Whirlaway and Citation competed on that ground.  I would have felt humbled to stand where Native Dancer left that track victorious before later retiring with a record of 21 wins in 22 lifetime starts.  I wish I could have watched my horses race on the same oval where Nashua and Swaps held a $100,000 match race and Jockey Eddie Arcaro became the two-time winner of the American Derby.  Yet, Washington Park was sold for commercial and residential development in 1992.  And, with that sale, the living monument to those moments disappeared in a dismal demolition.

If I were born a few decades earlier, I would have gone to the Wood Memorial when it was held at the former Jamaica Racetrack prior to its' demolition in 1960.  Jamaica Racetrack was where Omaha won the Wood on his road to becoming a Triple Crown Winner.  Native Dancer made his debut at Jamaica. Even Seabiscuit raced there.  And, before Bold Ruler retired to stud and gave the racing world Secretariat, he ended his career of 23 wins in 33 starts with his last race at the Jamaica Racetrack.  Yet, I'll never visit that park because the Rochdale Village Housing Development occupies the site now.  The greatness that took flight on that soil has long been forgotten in exchange for one more residential area.   

And finally, I wish I was at the former Sportsmans Park in Illinois in 2002 to watch War Emblem capture a victory in the Illinois Derby and stamp his ticket to Churchill Downs to race in the Kentucky Derby.  But, it appears that Fontenelle's proposition, "It takes time to ruin a world, but time is all it takes," proved true for Sportsman's far too soon.  By the time War Emblem set foot in the gates to win the Kentucky Derby at odds of 20-1, Sportsman's had already closed for good.  Whatever may have been celebrated from War Emblem's road to the roses the following year was ultimately replaced with plans to develop a shopping center on that site.

And now, Hollywood Park is facing closure with the same swan song from developers that, in time, it will become a commercial and residential development.  And sadly, it seems that time may be all it takes to demolish it.  

9 Comments:

Jennifer, while not demolished, the closure of the wondrous Hialeah broke my heart. Even now the fate of that track and many others hang in the balance, and the scales are tipping toward the next mall, parking lot or condo development. Now God knows we need more parking lots, but MUST they be where dreams lie? The recent disinterment of magical Noor and his subsequent transfer to a permanent home at Old Friends in Georgetown shows that if Charlotte Farmer can get the job done (and by golly! SHE DID), others can come along with the dreams remembered and do a small bit for racing, its' horses and heroic jockeys. Since horses have been the partners of men far longer than cars have been, and will be long after the last drop is drilled and the last barrel refined and sold, they will be again. So all you mall and parking lot and condo developers might rethink what to do with all that green space. Just maybe there's a small spot in Heaven for all those who pull back from the brink just before it's too late. We can only hope!

YE GODS! HOLLYWOOD PARK CONDOS??? I give up; the thought is too tragic to contemplate. All we have left of the Bay Meadows and Washington and Sportsmans and Jamaica are old photographs in an old book, but there is still time and after all, that's what your column is all about right?

Thanks for your lovely, nostalgic words. Maybe there's a good guy with a white hat just waiting for a new mountain to climb and by reading this that guy just MIGHT have found his new mountain.

Cheers and safe trips.

Needler in Virginia 23 Sep 2011 11:28 PM

I can not believe that Hollywood Park will be no more.  It seems hard to fathom that the horsemen in California, as well as elsewhere would allow this to happen.  Don't we have enough shopping malls, many standing half empty and enough housing developments with foreclosures and short sale signs in front of them without destroying a place of beauty, history and just plain pleasure to the eye to behold.  I had the good fortune to have a filly I bred race there.  It was a thrill.  How can even the general population of the area allow this to happen?    

savvora1 24 Sep 2011 11:30 AM

Two of the closures you mentioned happened because of hair-brained ideas. Bay Meadows closed because of the requirement to convert the track to synthetic.  Sportsman's closed because the owners thought that an auto track could co-exist with a horse track.  When the car track went bust, it took the horses down with it.

Mufasa Thedog 25 Sep 2011 1:37 PM

Ms. Wirth-Ice. Why wonder? You could set up that foundation for the retirement and/or retraining of Thoroughbreds. You have a lovely manner of writing which if it is reflected in your speech would be a great asset in starting such a project. Just be sure to get some old-timey horseman or horsemen, maybe from Kentucky to back you.

Mary Zinke 25 Sep 2011 2:01 PM

It is a shame to see such wonderful and historical tracks close and than, literally be wiped clean in place of new development. Horse racing has faced many major issues in recent years: unsoundness,drugs,purchase prices to name a few. We the fans need to do something to increase our fan base.  Queen Z and RA really did help, but now they're gone and it will be several years before we see the foals.  Not only have the tracks disappeared, but the breeding institutions as well.  The Meadow where Secretariat hailed and Glen Riddle where the mighty Man O'War once trained.  I guess most "non fans" would say it's progress - I say differently.  I can only hope that what once was will be again...  

fuzzbert 25 Sep 2011 3:40 PM

Thank goodness Hialeah hasn't closed and been demolished yet.  Quarter horses are currently keeping it open; perhaps soon, Thoroughbreds shall return.  Since Breeders' Cup has made it clear that they won't return to the "remodeled" Gulfstream, wouldn't it be something if they could return to South Florida at Hialeah, with those flamingos in the infield!!!  I hope Brunetti, or whoever is running it, succeeds in doing just that.  Naahh!!  CDI and Magna would never let that happen.

Texohky 25 Sep 2011 6:37 PM

Ms. Wirth-Ice's article brought back many fond memories, including being at the Swaps-Nashua match race at old Washington Park.  I was all of eight years old at the time, but to this day, I well remember the electricity in the air generated by the enormous crowd.  And needless to say, I wish the place was still around.  I'll have the same feelings, too, about Hollywood Park if it closes.  I'll never forget standing three feet from Affirmed there and having him look me right in the eye.

But, as is said (because it's true), things do change and nothing lasts forever.  So while I applaud Ms. Wirth-Ice's sentiments and her obvious respect for the history of the game, I hope she doesn't expend too much time and energy in trying to resist the inevitable.  If the land a given racetrack sits on will be worth far more to its owners with houses or a shopping mall on it instead, more often than not, it will sooner or later be "Goodbye, racetrack."

johnaugustwest 26 Sep 2011 12:20 PM

Are you forgetting Hialeah?  I am glad that someone finally came to their sense before this landmark was trashed to make way for condos.

PomDeTerre 27 Sep 2011 5:59 AM

You know how much I love this article and am glad to see that Bloodhorse had the sense to publish it.  You are right about a fund to help tracks if needed.  Tory

merrywriter 08 Oct 2011 7:26 PM


Thoroughbred Bloggers Alliance RSS Feed