BloodHorse.com

Little Things Still Count - by Jeff Klenner

18 Comments

It is my belief that today’s racetrack executives are prone to treating patrons as a commodity. They don’t honor the fact that fostered by familiarity and memories of days gone by, most fans have a strong identification with their local tracks. This attitude is not unlike the allegiance that fans often have to their local sports franchise. However, it is a double-edged sword, since the same fans may, at times, be harshly critical and vocal about the problems suffered and mistakes committed by such entities.

Such criticism is not, in itself, a bad thing. Anyone who has studied modern management principles will tell you that customers who complain are your best friends—because research shows that the majority of people do not bother to report their unsatisfactory experiences. Meaning that most patrons instead become ticking time bombs—if you disappoint them, they are more likely to just not come back rather than bother finding someone to whom they should voice their complaints.

The key, then, is to encourage your customer base to provide feedback directly to management. Part and parcel of that is for track executives to be visible and accessible to patrons on a daily basis. Many tracks employ “hosts and hostesses” to greet customers and help acquaint novice horseplayers with some of the intricacies of handicapping and wagering. That is all well and fine, but it is not a substitute for direct management involvement in being both visible to and approachable by customers.

While I thoroughly understand how busy track managers can be on a daily basis, it is still crucial that they spend at least half the race day in the clubhouse, grandstand, track apron, and simulcast area rather than retreat to their offices for the majority of that time. The importance of this cannot be overstated. In addition, it is not sufficient to simply walk around in a suit, looking important but entirely unapproachable (perhaps due to ongoing discussions with other staff members, cell phone conversations, or an otherwise occupied manner or appearance). Instead, the manager should have a large and conspicuous name tag with his or her name and title and be wearing an inviting smile while continuously greeting and speaking with persons young and old, those dressed casually or more formally, and those attending solo or in groups.

The prominent presence of high-level managers is something I fail to see at the vast majority of racetrack facilities I visit and, yet, I view it as a genuinely delinquent shortcoming. Suggestion boxes are not a substitute for sympathetic and understanding faces. If the visible, friendly, approachable manager profile I suggest is employed, the track’s patrons will indeed recognize and appreciate the attention given to customer satisfaction. A secondary benefit, of course, is that track employees also get to witness this sort of interest and involvement on the part of management and they take notice of the example of managers “walking the customer service talk” as well.

One of the things that I, as a track manager, used to do at the end of the race day was to position myself outside the main exit prior to the running of the final race on the card. Then as the crowd filtered out after the race, I would smile to people and thank them for coming—almost as if every one of them were a visiting dignitary who had been sent a personal invitation to attend on that day.

This sort of personal attention can take significant time out of a busy manager’s schedule, but while the benefits might not be readily measurable, they are nevertheless substantial. We operate in an entertainment industry with plenty of competition for the consumer’s dollar. In this sort of competitive environment, any differentiator you can place between you and that other alternative is important. And human nature being what it is, people will always recognize and appreciate warm, friendly, and sincere contact with someone who aptly conveys that the customer’s patronage is very much appreciated.

Jeff Klenner is a former management professor and consultant to Fortune 500 corporations. He has worked in several capacities in the horse racing industry, including a stint as director of operations at The Downs at Albuquerque and The Downs at Santa Fe. Jeff can be contacted at mail@klenner.us

18 Comments:

please forward this article to all north american racetrack front offices for posting

local owner 12 Aug 2008 2:56 PM

Well spoke, Jeff, thanks.

da3hoss 12 Aug 2008 3:47 PM

Jeff are you sure you did not work at La Mesa when they were know as the friendly track.Saw more hand shaking there by management than at a big city obstetrics wing in front of the babies

LORY 12 Aug 2008 5:09 PM

Hello Jeff...Thank you for the long overdue wakeup call to these so-called racetrack executives whom have adpoted an attitude of hubris and do not comprehend the most vital and essential word in business today..And that is attrition..The key to successful business is new business otherwise you are out of business..One must continually replenish it...Thats the bottom line...These people are clueless....Apathetic...They seem to pander to the owners and their connections..the trainers particularly on an vital stakes day when an out of town horse(s) ships in for their stakes of the day...Pre and post race these same people just evaporate and are non-existant...I have yet to see any of the track officials walk the grounds to say hello to the fans and discuss racing..how they are enjoying themselves and what improvements can be made..and so forth...This is sales 101..Apparently these people never took the course or fell asleep in class when it was given... And you mention dignitaries..and VIPS..everysingle fan whom walks thru those turnstiles is an VIP..dignitary...They may not be an owner/trainer or some elected/appointed offical or whatever..but sans the fans..the game is over...With what is happening today in the sport..and with the strong possibility of federal intervention in some quarters..I do not know how these people can be so aloof and distance themselves from the fans whom support them and pay their salaries...If the time ever comes when they have to shutter their doors permenently due to economics..they will then ask themselves where did I go wrong and if I had an opportunity to do it all over again..Classic example after last years Breeders' Cup conducted at Monmouth Park..You would think that w/the advent of this current meeting in early May they would have kiosks positioned throughout the plant w/staff broaching all of the fans and eliciting their thoughts regarding last years memorable events and if the Breeders'Cup did indeed spawn an newer and younger fan base and if now racing has become an entertainment venue for them? With the current meet reaching conclusion in September...not only do I not see any executives walking the apron..parking area and so forth...yet alone any post Breeders'Cup follow up...Ouch..Ouch....Attrition..Attrition...Thanx always Jeff for the window...Steve Stone..East Hanover..New Jersey..

STEVE STONE 12 Aug 2008 5:15 PM

In over 30 yrs of going to ractracks and OTB'S the only person who actually cared and provided the service he was selling was Rick Moore at Hoosier Park.The rest do nothing yet bemoan the fact that people would rather play online.If bettors were provided the tools they needed without being nickeled and dime to death they would still be betting at the track.In IL over the last 10 yrs I was asked to pay .05 for a pkg of catsup or mustard for my hot dog,forced to buy 2 programs to get the full DELMAR card.Split between day and night simo programs.IL bettors at Balmoral for live harness racing receive a smaller mutual than people playing across the line in IN.Play a simulcast race from any where in the US and see your mutual reduced by 2.5%,they have even reduced 2.20 payouts down to 2.10.I could go on but if you want to see how not to treat the bettors come and visit a track and get nicked for every transaction.A decent bettor will end up paying out 50-100 dollars a day for the pleasure of playing in IL and they wonder why people play on line or across the state line.

MMoneta 12 Aug 2008 6:42 PM

Jeff, you’ve framed the situation quite well. Currently, individuals leading this industry have several aspects in common:

• Few know much about the product being sold,

• Even less insight exists about customers who purchase it,

• What is known is a source of disaffection in that core users aren’t the least bit like themselves,

• The belief that “they’ll come anyway”,

• Few have ideas to tap new markets and,

• The belief that the core product is fine.

Even contemporary management tends to be top-down.  Unfortunate as allocations for budget and expertise will continue lag behind the vastly more profitable side of the economic (racino) house.   I fear we find ourselves in an ever-shrinking fraternity and the horizon isn’t at all promising.

David 13 Aug 2008 10:54 AM

Poor customer service is my biggest gripe having worked in that field myself, I tend to be harsher than most if I get terrible customer service and have no problems with letting management know for if you do not tell someone how will they know they have an issue that needs to be fixed. As for the racetracks I do wish that their customer service would improve but I think that they believe the only people coming to the tracks are diehard gamblers who could careless about service, food and cleanliness not that all diehard gamblers are filthy, I think you get my meaning however about how tracks are in general and I love going to Hollywood Park and Santa Anita with my husband and when our boys were little would take them with us as well. Some have tried to have a family atmosphere but still need improvements in that area. Attendance is dropping so they need to make it family and dating couple friendly. Just an opinion.

Julie L. 13 Aug 2008 1:48 PM

I feel Dover Downs similcast is excellent. Great betting machines and TV at no charge. They have a hoseracing hostess that looks after things and responds to your request. They mail you free matching $2 weekly wagering coupons every month. Mutual personnel are very courteous and friendly. They even comp for Buffet as a rebate on your Fast Bet Card. All drinks, soda and coffee are $1 with free refills all day. This is the way to treat customers and show you that they want  you to return.

Millpond 13 Aug 2008 5:11 PM

Good article. The lack of attention to patrons extends to Breeders Cup. If racing was interested in their live fans, they would not charge ridiculous prices for the Breeders Cup ($600 for a grandstand seat?). I know they think the Breeders Cup is like the Super Bowl, an "event". But that is only in the minds of the racing industry, not the general public. Here in LA, where local media care so little about racing (the daily newspaper no longer covers it at all), racing has a golden opportunity to get people to the track on Breeders Cup day(s). But they are flubbing it, royally. And of course the two "big event" horses apparently are not running.    

DWLa5 13 Aug 2008 6:09 PM

I have been to numerous eastern tracks, and the only place I have felt any type of consideration of the type you describe is at Keeneland. At Mountaineer, the closest thoroughbred track to my hometown of Pittsburgh, I would expect management to spit at me on the way out the door based on the way they seem to go out of their way to make watching horseracing unpleasant. The track employees sometimes try to be nice, but usually the track policies discourage this effort. Suprisingly Philadelphia Park was second best to Keeneland-generally welcoming (as a Pittsburgher this is very difficult to say) and seemed to actually appreciate my patronage. Penn National was fairly neutral, Presque Isle reminiscent of Mountaineer-"get out of the way, you anachronism, these people want to play the slots!" Racinos may be the financial short-term life support for horseracing, but unless they start to actually focus on serving the horseracing fan base like customers the patient will still die from neglect.

kevin morris 13 Aug 2008 9:32 PM

The racing industry never did understand how to market the sport and apparently it extends to the customer service arena as well.

Bill 14 Aug 2008 11:04 AM

In my experience, especially at Ca fairs, even new customers are left on their own. No attempt to encourage a return trip.

Ken Woodall 14 Aug 2008 12:18 PM

promote the sport...most tracks just don't have a clue...

Bellwether 14 Aug 2008 7:26 PM

I have attended and attend most tracks in both California and Kentucky.  I am not a clubhouse patron, but simply a general admission customer.  Over 40+ years I've become conditioned to not expecting anykind of real customer service or customer appreciation.  I've found this to be true pretty much across the board.....with one standout exception, Keeneland in Lexington.  In layman's terms, "they get it"!  But more importantly, they clearly know how to execute customer service and customer appreciation.  And I truly believe their customer service attitude/appreciation is genuine, not contrived.

I have no illusion that the others will ever get it.  My opinion (and every man is entitled to his opinion) is that they lack the real business skills and understanding, to make meaningful customer service/appreciation happen.  But what I find even more disconcerting, is these are the executives, G.M.'s, and managers who standby scratching their heads, wondering why on track attendance has reached abysmal low levels.  In layman's terms, "they don't get it".

AEM 15 Aug 2008 8:22 PM

I hope you have a few Poster Sized for NORTHLANDS PARK, Ab

Not Impressed 16 Aug 2008 12:52 AM

Great article! Sadly, most racetrack executives do not have a clue of providing world class customer service.

Turf Paradise, Hawthorne and Los Alamitos are horrible.  The places are filthy, the front line help are unfriendly at best.  Del Mar charges too much.  

Randy Sampson thinks like you do, he is on a first name basis with many of his  customers.  His front line staff are friendly and helpful. The food quality is generally better than most sport venues.

However, world class customer service is having a clean facility, the middle management and supervisory staff that is approachable, betting machines that work, a highly trained front line staff that can help ALL levels of fans for ALL their needs.

Every employee and management need to understand they are sales people and must do everything to get every fan to spend money once they are inside their facility.

TPSMKEMK 17 Aug 2008 2:51 AM

Not Impressed: I hear you. Worked on the backside and owned horses in the 80's and 90's at NP and StpP.But you know they are non-profit not private. Saying that they should understand customer service.

Wanda 20 Aug 2008 12:17 PM

Your article hit the right spot.  In the olden days, Saul Silberman, owner of Tropical Park, FL; Doug Donn of Gulfstream Park, FL, Chick Lang, Pimlico, MD; and Phil Iselin of Monmouth Park, NJ walked the clubhouse and grandstand most everday.  Visits to the backside were also remembered.  Dan Perlsweig, trainer Lord Avie 1981 eclipse award winner and Champion 2 year old, resident of Monmouth Beach NJ and Hollywood, FL

DANDDAN 23 Aug 2008 12:21 PM