BloodHorse.com

Search Blood-Horse.com

What If There Was No Curlin?

 By Patrick Patten, Handride

Look, I'm on the fence too.  I think Curlin is a horse for the decade:  An absolute monster who has proven his mettle on more than one continent.  He is a horse whose races will be watched years from now, both wins and losses. HOWEVER, I don't believe he's a lock in the Breeders' Cup Classic, so instead of trying to come up with an excuse I'll just pretend he's not in the race and let reality provide the need or non-need of an excuse.  He's not a speedster so he wouldn't affect the pace of the race anyways. 

What is the pace of this race?  I'm guessing Smooth Air and Fairbanks play a game of "You take it.  No you take it.  By all means you take it."  Colonel John, Raven's Pass, and maybe Go Between should occupy the second flight.  I'm imagining a pretty bunched up group with not a lot of pace.  Now, all the jockeys are probably thinking the same thing, so look for a surprise horse to try and steal away early or entering the final turn. 

We all know that the track has made it a little easier on the early speed types, but with none in here I'm looking for a horse who might make the middle move and keep that pace going.  (Remember we're pretending Curlin, who fits that bill perfectly, isn't in the race).  Raven's Pass interests me when I read his trip comments.  He's rated, led throughout, sustained his run over 1f, and gets the hands of Dettori - sounds pretty enticing.  In fact, both Duke of Marmalade and Henrythenavigator have some good things going for them, but I'm not betting an all Euro trifecta (famous last words?).  Duke might have peaked a while back and the Arc was a sign for a horse going downhill, and Henry might have the same case of being tired.  So, I'm left with the Americans who have nice middle moves.  I've seen Smooth Air do it, and while that's a bomb of a pick, I feel good that he'll outrun his odds.  Go Between is on the rail, which has been a death sentence recently at Oak Tree, but Gomez is the best jockey in the country and I'm sure he could get a donkey home in any race. 


If there was no Curlin:

Top Pick: Raven's Pass  

Minor Awards: Smooth Air, Go Between, Tiago    

5 Comments:

First, the top Europeans got b eat up pretty bad by a fillie their last trip...and that was only 3 weeks ago. The lone horse not in that group, Raven's Pass, got beat up by the top Europeans earlier in the year!  So to make it short...I'm dropping all the Europeans!  Not enough rest,they have never run on the surface, and I seriously doubt their overall talent!

I am surprised that you have basically left out the horses with proven records on Synthetic!  Colonel John is certainly a better 3 year old than Smooth Air but I don't like that he trained up until the race.  His first start after the Derby proved to me he needs a race to get into top form!  Go Between is much the choice over Tiago.  Yes he got a bad draw, but I still like his chances.

I find it funny that the type of race you discribed is the exact race that Casino Drive tends to run...staying near the pack and then having enough left to pull away.  I don't think he is the one though.  

If there was no Curlin, I would go with Go Between and box the exacta with Casino Drive and Colonel John.  I would also throw Tiago into the mix for the Trifecta.

But reality says that Curlin is the horse to beat.

davison_dad 23 Oct 2008 2:02 PM

I just can't imagine this race without CURLIN!!! I don't want to!

GO CURLIN!!!!!!

CURLINLOVER 23 Oct 2008 2:28 PM

What's wrong with getting beat by a filly? She was amazing, regardless of her gender.

IF Curlin wasn't in the race, I think I would say Go Between.

Melissa 23 Oct 2008 2:46 PM

To rip on the Europeans by saying they "got beat up pretty bad by a filly" is somewhat disrespectful to Zarkava.  Let's get over this gender focus people.  Zarkava is a female and she is also possibly the greatest horse in the world.  And if she is not, Zenyatta may be.  These two females have never lost.  Unfortunately, we have to listen to Rick Dutrow and others joke that Curlin got beat by a girl.  And what a girl she was!  And Eight Belles beat 18 boys in the Derby.  Why can't a great horse be a great horse regardless of sex?

Tom 23 Oct 2008 4:27 PM

It's quite obvious most of us don't watch too much Euro racing. I watch a bit of it.

No Curlin I would have to go with the Duke, and probably Go between, casino drive underneath.

The Duke because I think he will love the firmer faster surface. yes he has had a really long campaign but he is a quality horse. His Arc performance You could through out since he was not really being pointed up to that race and also because he didn't like the soft going. I think he is the best horse in Europe, He is a fighter and will battle any horse to the line.

Go between gets the second nod , because since the departure of heat seeker (my original favorite) he has bean the monster on the synthetic and has to be at least top 3.

Casino drive would be my pick for third because he is just so talented, and i see the race setting up much to his liking. I have him on the lead coming into the final turn and it would take some running for them to get by him.

If there was no curlin, but there is

All this said. I think Curlin is the man in this race regardless of the pace and am looking forward to seeing what he does.

Citicivil 23 Oct 2008 4:47 PM

Leave a Comment

All comments are moderated and must be approved before they are posted. The blog author reserves the right to edit or omit any comment.

  (Appears with your comment) (required)
  (Will not be published) (required)
  (required)

Thoroughbred Bloggers Alliance

Thoroughbred Bloggers Alliance RSS Feed

Click Here to download BloodHorse.com Widgets!