BloodHorse.com

Search Blood-Horse.com

Will the Breeders' Cup Be Able to See Beyond Sea the Stars?

By Rob Fundter, The Amateur Capper   

After winning the Prix de l’Arc de Triomphe for his undefeated, six race G.1 2009 campaign, the Irish “Horse of the World” may skip the Breeders’ Cup; the new star of the “World Thoroughbred Championship” weekend…it’s locally based LOOKIN AT LUCKY!

The Breeders’ Cup World Thoroughbred Championships may have to endure another major defection of a 3 y.o. with uncommon ability.  RACHEL ALEXANDRA has been shut down for the year…old news.  After a dazzling Arc win, SEA THE STARS is more unlikely to ship to Santa Anita than his connections led the media to believe in the weeks leading into the storied race at Longchamp.  The absence of both horses will be disappointing, no doubt.  Fret not, horse racing fans…as Yoda from the Star Wars series once predicted when Anakin Skywalker was lost to the dark side, “There is another…”

LOOKIN AT LUCKY made the G.1 Norfolk S. look deceptively easy.  For just over ¾ of the race, the professionalism that he showed in three prior wins was on display from the young son of SMART STRIKE.
He usually breaks well and rates kindly until GARRETT GOMEZ gives him the cue to “go”.  Even when he broke from the rail in the G.1 Del Mar Futurity, he waited patiently at the rear until GOMEZ decided to chance a rail run or sweep around horses on the backside and turn.  LOOKIN AT LUCKY runs inside, between horses, and can sweep around his competition.  He has a magnificent stride, effortless and simple.  LOOKIN AT LUCKY exudes class in every race he runs.  His dominance of the Southern California juvenile crop was emphasized in the Norfolk S. stretch run.

The 1 ¾ length margin of victory was a testament to the immense talent of the BOB BAFFERT trainee.  It sure wasn’t because he was giving 100% the entire length of the stretch.  Once he hit the lead, LOOKIN AT LUCKY pricked his ears and started to pull himself up.  After all, that was about the distance he’d run when he won the Del Mar Futurity.  He’d passed his competition and saw nothing but empty track ahead…LUCKY thought the race was over.

The HRTV isolation picked up the detail beautifully.  GOMEZ spanked the colt a few times and reminded him of his unfinished businesses with his signature, emphatic crosses.  LOOKIN AT LUCKY twitched his left ear back as if to say “Oh, do you want me to care about that plucky little colt on the rail that I’d already passed?  I’m sorry, I thought he was done.  I hear TREVOR DENMAN saying he’s trying hard to come back so I’ll turn on the afterburners and put him farther in the rear view mirror, okay?” 

LUCKY proceeded to pin both ears back, stuck his neck out and lengthened his stride while widening to a comfortable lead in a matter of 100 yards.  I had to laugh out loud at what I’d just seen on the replay which stirred interest from my children, who at this point in their lives put up with my love of the sport more than they share the passion.  I replayed what I’d seen three times, pointing out how professional LOOKIN AT LUCKY was through the running of the first 7 furlongs of the race.  Then I showed them how “green” the colt still was despite apparently having learned his lessons.  I paralleled their young lives and experiences to LOOKIN AT LUCKY’s Norfolk run.  Sports, human or equine, have always been terrific teachers in my lifetime and I use them whenever I can to guide my children’s development.

LUCKY, not unlike the developing human child, will need to learn how to compete at the top of this game through failure.  He’s that talented grade school athlete who runs over and around his less proficient classmates.  You remember the kind, built like an athlete already with muscles showing where the other boys still have baby fat.  There may even be a bit of facial hair to intimidate his competition a little more.  He’s a nice kid, not demoralizing his competition because he just doesn’t know he’s that much better than his friends.

Then, it happens…some of the others develop out of that awkward stage and begin to challenge the status quo.  A terrific equine example is the 2007 3y.o. crop.  STREET SENSE was the upset, daylight winner of the Breeders’ Cup Juvenile, Champion 2y.o. of 2006, and became the first horse to break the BC Juvenile/Kentucky Derby jinx.  He left a troubled CURLIN, who entered the Derby undefeated and untested, in his wake.

But CURLIN learned from his Derby run to snatch victory from the hands of defeat.  Two weeks later, STREET SENSE was on the verge of competing for the elusive Triple Crown when he stormed past CURLIN in upper stretch to open up by more than a length.  Then the competitive light bulb clicked in and CURLIN surged back on the outside to win the Preakness by a nose.

So, who will be LOOKIN AT LUCKY’s foil?  Will he become the next SILVER CHARM, a true competitor who will beat most top class horses if given the ability to eyeball them home.  At this stage, it appears that we’ll have to wait until the Triple Crown trail to find out who will emerge from this crop as the legitimate challenger.  Will it be DUBLIN?  How about BACKTALK?  Can HOT DIXIE CHICK become 2010’s RACHEL ALEXANDRA?

The only relative certainty will be that LOOKIN AT LUCKY is the most likely Breeders’ Cup race winner.  If he succeeds as expected, he will become the 2009 Eclipse Award winner for Juveniles and becomes the early Kentucky Derby favorite.

Is there yet another?  At this point it appears that LOOKIN AT LUCKY is THE ONLY ONE!

35 Comments:

Of course the Breeders Cup can see

beyond Sea The Stars,they saw beyond Rachel Alexandra did,nt they?.There is still a lot of racehorse talent out there to make this an memorable Breeders Cup as usual.Sea The Stars has not been totally ruled out but even if it does not happen there is always the next champion waiting around the corner.Perhaps it will be Lookim At Lucky.

John T. 08 Oct 2009 10:39 PM

I found Blind Luck's win in the

Oak Leaf much more visually impressive than Looking at Lucky's win in the Norfolk. Yet no comment on her.

AnneM 08 Oct 2009 10:53 PM

I could not agree more with this blog if I had written it myself!! This year is as wide open as any I can remember, and I have seen all the Br. Cups. If you hit either pick 6, you WILL get paid!! Heck, for that matter, the pick 4's will probably be sweet. I make my bankroll every year at this time. It's just like my mother always said: " DO YOUR HOMEWORK ". IT PAYS !! Good Luck to all.

WinItALL4Fun 09 Oct 2009 1:35 AM

@John T.

Thanks so much for stopping in.  I read in an article that the BC and SA were going to pursue the connections of SEA THE STARS...I think that's wasted effort and part of why I wrote this.

I agree with you, there's a ton of talent that's going to show up and focusing on a young colt like LOOKIN AT LUCKY could be an angle to push (BAFFERT, PEGRAM, SMART STRIKE, same path as MIDSHIPMAN but won the Norfolk, synthetic/dirt Derby questions, etc.).

Amateurcapper 09 Oct 2009 11:10 AM

@ Anne M.

So kind of you to take the time to comment.  Difference of opinion, that's what this game is all about.

It wasn't that BLIND LUCK didn't do well...she held up the form of MI SUENO's Del Mar Debutante in which BLIND LUCK was a nice 2nd.  However, I thought the world of the latter who was head and shoulders better than BLIND LUCK before she was injured.  Here's links to two posts I wrote about her if you have time: (amateurcapper.blogspot.com/.../mi-sueno-dream-filly.html) and (amateurcapper.blogspot.com/.../darley-debutante-s-sept-5-2009.html)

I think there may be another filly shipping in or switching from turf to main track that will be tougher than BLIND LUCK in the BC Juvenile Fillies.

BLIND LUCK was impressive, but as I wrote it was the manner in which LOOKIN AT LUCKY won that stood out to me.

He's won four races and still hasn't really figured out the game!  Breeding, potential, proven trainer track record in big races, ownership no stranger to big horses/races...LOOKIN AT LUCKY, in my humble opinion, has more upside and the reason I focused on him.

Thanks again for reading!

Amateurcapper 09 Oct 2009 11:26 AM

@ WinItALL4Fun,

Thanks for stopping by and good luck this year.  ANNE M. says BLIND LUCK was more visually impressive than LOOKIN AT LUCKY.  Is there anyone that has caught your eye?  

After all, I'd like to get paid as well!  There'll be lots of horses to consider and differing opinions will assist us all in making stronger or weaker cases on the big days.

Enjoy the ride!

Amateurcapper 09 Oct 2009 11:31 AM

Probably if Gomez had chirped to LaL he would have gottern the same results as his "signature cross-spanking"...

Great atheletes rarely need "spankings".

Rachel A (for real) 09 Oct 2009 3:09 PM

@ Rachel A (for real),

Well, that's a debatable point.

I've never ridden a horse, but have seen plenty of great horses run in my lifetime.  I can't remember watching a big race, that was still undecided in deep stretch, where the jockey put the stick away.  Can you?

Until they rule that whips and crosses are "excessive" in horse racing, they'll be used.  I just don't think that a "Black Stallion" ride is anywhere in the future of the game.

Thanks for chiming in.

Amateurcapper 09 Oct 2009 4:35 PM

I wouldn't put Lookin at Lucky in the "relative certainty" column for the BCJ win just yet.  The Breeders Futurity is this weekend on Keeneland synthetic at the 1-1/16 distance.  The best finishers should be formidable in the BCJ.  Some are already proven on dirt, too.  

Concerning Luckys' foil, a 50-1 long shot flew past Baffert's big Derby star this year.  Then he finished up the track in the Preakness.  I really wish he'd prep his horses on real dirt once or twice before the Derby.  Until then, I'm not getting excited about his Triple Crown prospects.    

MEH 09 Oct 2009 7:06 PM

Cant wait for the Breeder's Cup regardless of who isn't coming!  I agree that Lookin at Lucky was very impressive - he is my Derby horse. And what breeding he has too!  From the male line of none other than the amazing Native Dancer who he also happens to trace back to 6 times in his overall pedigree!  It doesn't get any better than that IMO!

Racingfan 10 Oct 2009 10:39 PM

@ MEH,

Thanks so much for taking the time to comment...I love to read dissenting opinions.  Was there one that caught your eye this weekend?

I believe your theory holds a lot of water.  I'll take it a step further to say that the next Triple Crown winner will come out of the New York juvenile graded stakes races on dirt.  That seasoning helped SECRETARIAT, SEATTLE SLEW, and AFFIRMED.  However, there are always exceptions that prove the rule and I believe that LOOKIN AT LUCKY is exceptional.

No doubt that the Breeders' Futurity can give solid contenders...last year's winner SQUARE EDDIE finished 2nd, runner-up TERRAIN was 4th, and show horse PIONEEROF THE NILE finished 5th.

NOBLE'S PROMISE (1st) and AIKENITE (2nd) are solid contenders coming out of the race this year.

I believe that the Pro-ride edge that LOOKIN' AT LUCKY has, along with what I view as untapped potential, makes him the solid favorite for the BC Juvenile.  IMHO, with his next start known (if all goes as planned), he's the best "future wager" prospect for the Breeders' Cup, about four weeks out.

As for Bob Baffert and the Triple Crown, I think I read somewhere that he's debating a change in the synthetic-only preparation.  I believe that LUCKY will run on broken glass...that's how good he appears to be.  LUCKY is a really good colt who happened to be reared sprinting on synthetics because that's the juvenile game and SoCal is where his owner/trainer are based.  PIONEEROF THE NILE was switched from Bill Mott to Bob Baffert because of the synthetics, which was a big reason for his juvenile and 3y.o. success.  

PIONEEROF THE NILE was started long on the turf from the get-go by Bill Mott, so that means he was all distance in both performance and breeding and may have had some foot issues the turf/synthetics would have helped with.

As for PIONEER's Derby loss to improbable MINE THAT BIRD...I think the subsequent "flights" and crash landings of the Derby winner are proof that the slop made for a "once-in-a-lifetime" moment.  Look back at the tape...PIONEER was injured on that sloppy track; note how he was getting out down the lane after he got the lead.  The injury was probably undetectable prior to the Preakness.

Amateurcapper 11 Oct 2009 2:21 AM

This is very politely responding to you, with all good intentions:

It was the "signature" part that got me...and we just saw a big race, geesh I can't remember who it was, major brain cramp, last weekend where the jock lost the whip and the horse won by his good riding.

Jerry Bailey believes whips should be banned. An animal bred to do something does not need coersion. An animal with no talent or desire for the game shouldn't be in the game.

I love jockeys, appreciate their hard work and best intentions, so this is not an attack, just an observation, How many races has the jockey been out of sync with the horse's stride? The whip ill-timed, his body posture back as the horse moves forward...Or the whip distresses the horse and gets his mind off the race and onto the whip?

Who cares if it's a "big" race? A horse runs with the talent he's born with...a horse running his best effort deserves a fair ride, not a whip.

I worked years ago for a small 20 horse racing stable...mucking, walking, rubbed, wrapped, iced, tubbed, exercise. I ride dressage, hunter and have shown other disciplines. Bred and trained Arabian horses.

I breed top calibre police and search and rescue K-9's...who need ZERO compulsion to do the job they're bred to do.

;-)

Rachel A(for real) 11 Oct 2009 9:02 AM

@ Racingfan,

Thanks for taking the time to read/comment.

Obviously we share the enthusiasm.  BTW, LUCKY's 1/2 brother KENSAI goes in the G.2 Jerome today trying to add to the family legacy.

Enjoy the ride!

Amateurcapper 11 Oct 2009 11:43 AM

Amateurcapper said  "I can't remember watching a big race, that was still undecided in deep stretch, where the jockey put the stick away."

IF that's true, does that justify the jockey continuing to beat the horse when the race HAS BEEN put away?

tvnewsbadge 11 Oct 2009 11:45 AM

Certainly "the Breeders' Cup Be Able to See Beyond Sea the Stars"

Jess Jackson and the American horse racing community have already trashed talked this year's edition into total insignificance so the presence (or not)of Sea the Stars is not to make squat bit of difference when it comes to prestige and fan interest.

tvnewsbadge 11 Oct 2009 11:58 AM

The only problem with hitching your wagon to a 2-year-old star is that there is like a 50-50 chance that he (or she) will be purchased by Middle Eastern interests.  So they might win the Juvenile and then you won't see them for 6 months or more.  The sheiks have a synthetic track now, too, so wouldn't they especially want horses that run well at SA?  And we all know their offers can't be refused.

Pam S. 11 Oct 2009 1:11 PM

Rachel A,

     I believe the jock you are reffering to is the one who rode Music Note int the Beldame.

LDP 11 Oct 2009 1:38 PM

Rachel A(for real),

I appreciate your comments and apologize if I offended your sensibility regarding horse racing.  Your point about the whips is terrfic.  Right now, for better or worse, they're "legal" encouragement.  It'd be better to do away with them completely instead of going to different whips or try to regulate how much is "excessive" whipping.

They've moved to whips that are easier on the horses in Canada.  

I wasn't trying to glamorize the whips, but I did want to make a point about how GOMEZ got LOOKIN AT LUCKY's attention.  Having heard my share of stretch runs, the crosses and whips are used when the "chirp" and the "screams" just aren't enough.  GOMEZ is easily identifiable from his stretch run mechanics when he uses a cross...ie. his "signature".  There's a reason he's as sought out as BAILEY was in his day...he's the best.  Up to now, the owners and trainers who use him don't seem to mind his tactics.  I'll trust the judgment of names like KATHY WALSH, CARLA GAINES, BOBBY FRANKEL, BOB BAFFERT, EOIN HARTY, WINSTAR FARMS, JUDDMONTE FARMS, AHMED ZAYAT, MIKE PEGRAM, etc.

As for BAILEY wanting whips banned, that is a noble pursuit and would be best to showcase the innate ability of the horses.  He's tied for the winningest BC Classic jockey (5 times) and he used the whip rather sparingly relative to his counterparts.  Then again, he was usually on the best horse anyway.

When I was young, I remember a stakes level sprinter named MR. PRIME MINISTER trained by BUSTER MILLERICK (I later found out he trained NATIVE DIVER).  He always raced without a whip.  Career totals:  75-20-10-10 including the G.3 Los Angeles H. at age 7!  So, it can be done.

However, if the whips are taken away, the reins and crosses will become more intense when you would rather have the jockeys go only "hands and heels".  Sport, equine or human, is inherently aggressive and athletes are pushed to their limits.

I'll leave you to ponder, do you think your namesake, RACHEL, or ZENYATTA has had a better year and/or career?  

Amateurcapper 11 Oct 2009 2:33 PM

@tvnewsbadge,

Thanks for your comments.

As for "continuing to beat the horse", what race are you referring to?  Of course, the jockeys should put the stick away when clear of the field.  MIKE SMITH did with ZENYATTA on Saturday, a champion with 12 prior wins without a loss, but even she despite 12 prior wins without a loss started to prick her ears and lose her focus while LETHAL HEAT and COCOA BEACH were both in stiff drives and making up the deficit.  The jockeys just can't seem to win on this point.

RE:  Presitge and fan interest, I believe the Breeders' Cup will always have compelling stories.  The way I see it, when someone doesn't come the door is open for another to step up.

Amateurcapper 12 Oct 2009 1:17 AM

@ Pam S.,

I know, it's hard to project juveniles forward.  Even tougher when you throw the Dubai money into the equation.

However, I think that LOOKIN AT LUCKY's owners are wealthy enough that they wanna roll the dice to see how far this colt can take them.  They're old enough to have amassed a small fortune, yet young enough to take risks.  It's not often this kind comes along and I believe they are very cognizant of that.  It's gonna have to be Mega Millions type money to get this group to flinch.

Thanks for reading/commenting!

Amateurcapper 12 Oct 2009 1:24 AM

@LDP and Rachel A (for real),

I went back to look at the Beldame...JOHN VELAZQUEZ didn't drop the stick, he just never saw the need to uncock it.  He kept his hands in the same place they were the entire race.  MUSIC NOTE was that much better than UNBRIDLED BELLE.  That race was nothing more than a workout that happened to be during a race.  A really good horse in an overmatched field makes the jockey look like a genius 100% of the time.

Amateurcapper 12 Oct 2009 1:39 AM

Mr. Amateurcapper,

And thanks for your answer.  I'm looking forward to seeing this exciting colt in person next month.

Pam S. 12 Oct 2009 1:17 PM

The only other race I can think the lost whip could be in then was Awesome Gem's last out in the Hawthorn Gold Cup.

LDP 12 Oct 2009 3:19 PM

Blind Luck looks real good....Zenyatta duh!.....Gayego looked lights out/will play him over Zensational....Colonel John/Richards Kid are playbacks.....would love if Bruce's Dream draws into the turf sprint.....Ventura......Lookin At Lucky....that's my West Coast List---turf races are gonna be Euro-Tough, if the East Coast doesn't come through USA is gonna get a butt kickin'--again! Also if Zenyatta goes in the filly race---Music Note and friends are in big trouble--again!

Matthew W 13 Oct 2009 11:17 AM

Well, given the title of this blog, it seems an appropriate place to comment on the retirement of Sea the Stars.  I'm disappointed he won't be coming to the BC, but the trainer had stated clearly that if the horse ran in the Arc, that would be it for the year.  As it turns out, that's it, period.

That is the trouble with great horses these days, IMO.  They are just that, great, but here and gone so fast they're like shooting stars.  I read that the British press described the youthful owner of Sea the Stars is "immeasurably wealthy."  So unless a soundness issue is involved, I'm not sure why the horse can't run another season.  He could try to conquer the U.S. or run in Dubai in 2010, or he could have a less ambitious campaign, whatever ....  Why the rush to stud?

I know this will elicit the usual admonitions about "the owner can do what he wants, it's his horse."  (Or at least it would if it was on one of the other blogs.)  I understand that, but still wanted to express my thoughts.

Pam S. 13 Oct 2009 11:19 AM

SOOOOO, How did those west coast 2 yr olds do this weekend at Keeneland?   Lookin at Lucky is nothing special

Pickem Pete 13 Oct 2009 6:20 PM

I would like to see the Zenyatta camp declare their horse for the Classic and challenge the owners of Sea of Stars, Rachel Alexander and Summer Bird to bring their best game to the track and settle the debate in the arena where it belongs.

Oneeyedpirate 13 Oct 2009 9:48 PM

Given the title of this blog they will see beyond the stars,they'll see the tails of Rip Van Winkle and Mastercraftman.

datflippinrabbit 14 Oct 2009 10:18 AM

@ LDP,

Took a look at the Hawthorne Gold Cup...no dropped whip there either.

Amateurcapper 15 Oct 2009 12:46 AM

@ Matthew W.,

That's quite a list you've compiled...many will have very big shots in their respective events.

I'm not sure what to think about the BC Classic at this point...COLONEL JOHN is a personal favorite, but losing to GITANO HERNANDO was a serious indictment on him and U.S. (SoCal)horses...RIP VAN WINKLE and ZENYATTA look like the top of that crop but EINSTEIN has had success in SoCal and I will give CJ and RICHARD'S KID another chance with decent, recent experience on the track.  This year's race looks wide open to me.

BRUCE'S DREAM disappointed me a bit in his Cal Cup loss...would appear a bit over his head in the Breeders' Cup.  CALIFORNIA FLAG is in good form but will wait until the field is known in the Turf Sprint.

MUSIC NOTE looks like stronger filly this year...that last win in the Beldame was soooo easy.  Didn't beat much, but did it the way a G.1 filly should.  She's a 1/2 to a G.1 winning turf miler who was very competitive vs. the boys.  If the Pro-ride continues to be kind to turf types, watch out for her breeding to move her even farther forward from her recent win and her 3rd last year in the Ladies Classic.

Amateurcapper 15 Oct 2009 12:59 AM

@ Pam S.,

I welcome your comments.  While I may not agree with every comment, each is considered respectfully and the reply as researched as can be.

SEA THE STARS' defection will probably keep me at home to watch the big races...he was the only reason left for me to splurge for the pricey admission.  

Maybe his name should have been DONTBLINKORULLMISSTHESTAR :-)!!!

But seriously, he's danced a lot of dances, like RACHEL did.  SEA THE STARS won an incredible 6 G.1's in Europe this year...the most CURLIN won in back-to-back HOY honors was 4 last year, INVASOR won 4 in his HOY campaign (6 straight from '06-'07), SAINT LIAM also took 4 in '05, GHOSTZAPPER only 3 in his HOY campaign.  SEA THE STARS is too special to take a chance with.

I do share your dismay at the continuation of early retirements.  Realistically, we may never have seen SEA THE STARS in person even if he'd raced at age 4.  He's Europe's treasure and for us to admire from afar (or via video!).

For international prestige, the Arc win will always trump the BC Classic or BC Turf.  The Dubai World Cup may have already surpassed the BC Classic in international prestige.  As much as you and I love U.S. racing, the international community looks down their collective noses at racing here with their best horses when their "second string" can win the BC Classic and BC Turf last year.

There's probably a very lucrative deal in place to send him to stud...in the end it's always about the Benjamins.

Thanks again for taking the time to comment.

Amateurcapper 15 Oct 2009 1:26 AM

@ Pickem Pete,

Difference of opinions...that's what makes talking about these magnificent animals so entertaining.  Thanks for taking the time to comment.  So if you don't like LOOKIN AT LUCKY, who are you lookin at?

Personally, I think the the MAIDEN colt MAKE MUSIC FOR ME was a horrible proposition vs. multiple winners in the Breeders' Futurity.  His good 4th in that race says volumes for LOOKIN AT LUCKY who's still not putting out 100%.  HURRICANE IKE, well he was a longshot there as he was here and ran like one.  Nothing should be gleaned from that effort when judging LUCKY.

Let me know your horse(s).

Amateurcapper 15 Oct 2009 1:37 AM

@ Oneeyedpirate,

Thanks for stopping by and commenting.

Unfortunately, as an old deck hand would understand, that talented ship has sailed.  RACHEL's resting.  SEA THE STARS has retired.

You will see SUMMER BIRD in the BC Classic and a buddy o' mine says this guys the nuts and should be respected big time in the Classic.

Don't push ZENYATTA's connections.  They'll make the right decision on their own, not because we scream for it.

My money's on Z going in the Classic as of today, for what that's worth.

Amateurcapper 15 Oct 2009 1:43 AM

@ datflippinrabbit,

RIP VAN WINKLE will go in the Classic, but MASTERCRAFTSMAN is reportedly being pointed to the Marathon...so maybe you're right, their competiion may see only their European rumps.

Thanks for taking the time to read/comment.

Amateurcapper 15 Oct 2009 1:47 AM

I can't think of anything else then, all I remember is that race was MUDDY!

LDP 15 Oct 2009 5:38 PM

Leave a Comment

All comments are moderated and must be approved before they are posted. The blog author reserves the right to edit or omit any comment.

  (Appears with your comment) (required)
  (Will not be published) (required)
  (required)

Thoroughbred Bloggers Alliance

Thoroughbred Bloggers Alliance RSS Feed

Click Here to download BloodHorse.com Widgets!