Making the Grade

The American Graded Stakes Committee may wake up to the reality that the graded stakes of summer and fall for 3-year-old horses fail to meet the criteria of grade I competition. But it’s likely the committee won’t.

The grade II Jim Dandy was recently moved up in class and the horses assembled probably suit the description. But the same grade II horses will return for the Travers (gr. I) and suddenly, they’ll assume loftier status.

Only one Jim Dandy runner─Arnold Zetcher’s Liaison, a bay colt by Indian Charlie that finished third─had won a grade I stakes. The best any of the others accomplished in a Triple Crown race was the third in the grade I Belmont Stakes that Atigun ran. Alpha, the winner of the Jim Dandy, finished 12th in the Kentucky Derby (gr. I)

Nevertheless, Alpha is a perfect two-for-two at Saratoga and has won half of his eight races. The meet’s leading jockey, Ramon Dominguez, working for trainer Kiaran McLaughlin on behalf of Godolphin, kept the son of Bernardini a length ahead of the pack throughout all but the last yards of the 1 1/8 miles and then added another length to his lead at the wire. Now, it’s on to that shot at a grade I.

In capturing the co-featured $600,000, Diana (gr. IT), Winter Memories, a pink daughter of El Prado, won her third race at Saratoga, her fourth graded stakes and her eighth race overall. She’s been amazingly reliable for trainer Jimmy Toner, coming back from the occasional set back in a fashion that’s fan-pleasing.

Despite less than ideal weather, there were several other performances worth noting on the Saturday, July 28 card. Juddmonte had gotten what it wanted from the well-bred Raison d’Etat only once in eight previous starts, but on Saturday the 4-year-old A.P. Indy colt delivered. He looked like the French foreign policy, moving right, moving left and moving right again in the stretch, but those who stood to prosper from him did.

In the second race, Ken and Sarah Ramsey were blessed by Charming Kitten in her very first start. In the third race, the red hot Starlight Stables produced another 2-year-old winner in Lawn Man. Both horses were trained by Todd Pletcher.

Lots of people who come to Saratoga for the races leave well before the feature race. Sitting in a lawn chair with dust between toes is okay for awhile, but at about the time the rains typically come, which is late afternoon, patience becomes challenging, especially if you can watch the action on television.

Last summer, NBC Sports televised feature races from Saratoga throughout the meet. But, this summer, there are the London Olympic Games and horse racing fans know all too well what has priority. That probably explains why so many stayed for both stakes. The crowd numbered 24,548, considerably fewer than the same day last year. 

Vic Zast is the author of The History and Art of 25 Travers. He has attended the races at Saratoga for 47 straight summers.


Leave a Comment:

Turf Writer Warren

Thanks Vic.  I have been grumbling about these ridiculous graded races for some time now.  They have been a joke for some time.  Part of the problem is you cannot have a director of racing at a a venue as part of the grading process.  Take this year's Eddie Read as an example.  Grade 1?  Insulting to say the least.  Not even worthy of grading period!  You have director of Del Mar racing Tom Robbins sitting on this committee.  Enough said.  Just forget about it.  Nobody wants to keep these so-called graded races up to date in the first place, even if they had an independent source doing the grading.  It's like having a student grade his own paper.  Same thing.  It doesn't work.  And it hasn't meant a thing for quite some time.  

29 Jul 2012 9:47 AM
Arts and Letters

In comparison to other countries, the US has way too many graded races.  If the number was cut in half, then maybe it would become something special again to have a grade 1 winner.  

29 Jul 2012 8:21 PM
Pedigree Ann

The Travers will attract not only runners from the Jim Dandy but also from the Haskell and the Curlin (a race for nonwinners of a graded race). The Jim Dandy and the Curlin (and to some extent the G1 Haskell) are PREPS for the Travers, where the trainers find out if their animals are fit and talented enough to go on to the better, longer test.

In the original formulation to create graded races, the 'graders' found that some prep races came out too high in the rankings - those races had good horses in who were getting ready for the big races. So they made the deliberate decision to lower the grades of many preps. For instance, the Seminole H, the 9f prep for the Widener H. might frequently have had a very good field (Citation, Forego, Intentionally, and Kelso were Seminole winners), but it was assigned a G2 ranking, because it was a prep. Would that the current 'graders' had continued this philosphy; we would have been spared the absurdity of prep races graded higher than the race being prepped for!(The Malibu vis-a-vis the Strub)

30 Jul 2012 8:35 PM

Recent Posts

Related Reading

More Blogs