BloodHorse.com

Search Blood-Horse.com

Heel Bulb Injuries 101: Big Brown's Latest Hoof Malady

Posted by Fran Jurga

In a previous entry, this blog provided details about the heel bulb injury that predicated the disappointing retirement of champion three-year-old Thoroughbred Big Brown. This post will give some background into the type of injury for those unfamiliar with foot anatomy and injury.

 


 

A horse's heel bulbs are similar to the fleshy part of the palm of your hand above the wrist, at the base of your thumb. The bulbs are in the back part of the foot, above the hairline and below the "waist" of the pastern. In this photo, which shows a foot cut in half, it is the brownish zone at the right that bulges out from the hoof. The heel bulbs are comprised of soft tissue, namely the digital cushion, a fat-cartilage mass that fills out the foot and provides multiple cushioning, circulation-enhancing and/or structural functions in maintaining the integrity and strength of the foot. The bulbs are covered with skin and hair and are not protected by hard hoof wall or sole. They are a vulnerable structure. (Photo courtesy of HorseScience.com)


This stakes horse at Keeneland suffered a heel injury that might have been similar to Big Brown's. Technically the heel bulbs are the area covered with hair, just below the horseshoer's thumb. The area was filled in and covered with acrylic and a glue on Polyflex shoe was applied by Curtis Burns. This photo was taken when the horse was well into the healing process. Sometimes the hind shoe scrapes down the back of the pastern over the heel bulbs and ripping off part of the heel or pulling off the front shoe. Thoroughbred racehorses frequently suffer from a grabbed quarter, heel bulb lacerations and coronet bruising and cuts because of toe grabs on their shoes. But, as Big Brown showed today, these injuries can occur even without toe grabs. Frequently a hind foot comes up and strikes the front foot when there is a gait abnormality, such as when horses are galloping on soft turf and the front foot stays on the ground a fraction of a second too long and the hind foot comes forward and strikes it. The injury frequently happens when horses scramble out of the starting gate, and can happen to hind feet when "clipping heels" with another horses. Some horses have conformational or coordination problems that designate them "hitters" and suffer from chronic lower leg and hoof injuries. They usually wear bandages, bell boots and have their hind shoes "set back" to reduce the chance of injury when training. Big Brown wore bell boots when schooling for the Belmont to protect his quarter crack patch.



One of Big Brown's feet in the spring of 2008: His heel bulbs are partially recruited into the hoof wall repair for his heel separations. (Ian McKinlay photo)


How bad can a heel bulb injury be? This is a case at the Rood and Riddle Equine Hospital's Podiatry Clinic, as featured in issue #79 of Hoofcare and Lameness Journal. Dr. Scott Morrison reconstructed the frog and over time, was able to restore the foot and the young Thoroughbred began its racing career wearing normal raceplates. Heel bulb injuries are common around farms, particularly wire cuts, horses catching a hoof in a cattle guard, pasture injuries, trailer loading mishaps, etc.


Aftermath of a heel bulb laceration: This ex-racehorse shows evidence of a severe injury earlier in its life. The horse is completely sound.

 

This post was originally published on October 13, 2008 at http://www.hoofcare.blogspot.com. Fran Jurga's Hoof Blog is a between-issues news service for subscribers to Hoofcare and Lameness Journal.

 

14 Comments:

His feet had problems with catching up with his courageous heart...

Thanks for the ride Brownie, I'll never forget you!

Windy City 16 Oct 2008 5:37 PM

Hindsight is always 20-20, but after 30 years in the training ranks should I have been presented with a horse of "Big Brown's" stature & valuation I might have considered putting a close fitting set of 1/4 boots on him? 1) They weigh next to nothing and 2) They would have afforded him a great deal of protection without his even being aware they were there. If your going to risk an injury you do it racing in the "Breeders Cup" not during a training session.

Having said this I do of course recall the odd error I've made with stakes horses......but I don't think I want to go there hmmmm.

TouchStone Farms 16 Oct 2008 6:28 PM

I still love Big Brown and hope that he lives a long life.

I also think that he has not been given the credit that he is due.

Luvthehorses 16 Oct 2008 7:04 PM

Great background information Fran!

Interesting that his injury occurred while working out on turf. Did his tendency to hit his legs while running make this a more likely injury to occur?

Robert 16 Oct 2008 7:34 PM

thanks for the post! I've heard about and seen a horse "grab". Some horses do it all the time, which is why they wear front wraps and the different shoes. it stinks that he won't be racing in the classic. i wanted to see him meet with the Big Boys. that was his true test for me. He'll be happy as a stud, livin the good life.

Flyinhome 16 Oct 2008 7:42 PM

Now Big Brown can join Smarty Jones.  Both were crowd pleasers.  I was so happy to see Big Brown come back for 2 more major wins after his Belmont tragedy!  Big Brown was a winner

Deborah Thomas 16 Oct 2008 7:43 PM

Thank you to everyone who read and/or commented on my post. I thought it might be helpful for people to see photos of similar (and worse) injuries.

I am sure that the trainer had reasons for sending the horse out to train without bell boots; I have photos of him training on other dates (on the dirt) with them on. And then again, maybe they forgot them back at the barn!

My personal theory is that it might have happened after the work if he shied at something and/or scrambled a bit. When you're on a horse, you feel and hear a break in the rhythm of the hooves hitting the ground and I haven't heard the rider mention a stumble or anything during the work.

What a tough break; maybe by the time his offspring hit the track we'll be able to do hoof transplants.

PS For "Robert", I don't know what his tendency to hit previously was, other than that he had rundown problems on his hinds after the Preakness and wore bandages on all fours when worked on the dirt recently, as documented by the Blood Horse. Horses can also interfere between front feet, not just hind to front.

I can't believe no one taped his work!

Fran Jurga 16 Oct 2008 10:26 PM

I hate to say this but I'm kinda glad he is not going to the BC. I would never ever wish an injury on any horse but I did not have a good feeling about the race. Nothing to do with winning or not winning. I've just had some fear(unfounded I'm sure)that he would breakdown. On to Three Chimneys and a date with the ladies! Thanks for this very informative article with pics.

gammyp6 16 Oct 2008 11:08 PM

I can believe no one taped his work! The media has been pathetic when it comes to even little tidbits, about Big Brown since the Belmont. I love Curlin, but I'm surprised we haven't seen articles on his "bathroom", eating and nap habits. I think the media went with all the negatives, leaving Brownie out, and went with the positives, which of course is Curlin. I'm sure we will hear much more about Curlin than Brownie after they are both retired as well. Brownie got a bad deal here and I think it's very sad. I will be screaming & cheering for Curlin next week along with everyone else. I just wish people would remember, they are living breathing horses, not robots.....

Thanks for the great post, very informative.

Have a great BC Day Everyone!

normajean81258 17 Oct 2008 12:15 AM

Norma, I and apparently many others believe that was the reason for hiding him out. They didn't want anyone to know what was going on with the colt, for whatever reason that may have been, only the connections know for sure. They didn't announce his workouts, just a vague every 6-7 days. THEY chose to withhold public access to the colt, THEY chose to train at track that is currently a training track only. I saw on here many times people trying to figure out what was going on with the colt. Of course it's not the colt's fault, but maybe the big crowds of onlookers and media made him nervous. Obviously he was so fragile hoofwise that the connections KNEW they were playing on borrowed time.

As far as hearing more about Curlin, yes I'm sure we will. As a stud he has shown to be more durable, more accomplished and has a little more longevity. Big Brown is the kind of stud prospect MANY people have complained about. One with an inherited problem that he has a high likelihood of passing on to his progeny.

Fran,

My own curiosity has been peaked by the seeming lack of preparation to prevent this type of injury. I saw something about front wraps, those would only have prevented the small cut. Bell boots may have helped, but not the rubber type that flop around. Perhaps the type used on rodeo horses may have, but the injury could very well have been that he caught the hoof just right and due to the fragile nature of his hoofwall, very little force was needed to break off the chunk. As far as when it happened, none of us really know, I doubt we ever will know exactly what happened.

Alex JH 17 Oct 2008 10:52 AM

Also Fran, Dutrow apparently said he grabbed the right front with the right rear.

Alex JH 17 Oct 2008 10:54 AM

Thank you for the information. I saw pictures of his hoof and how much of it was ripped off. Ow! Really bad hangnail! Seriously, I have been anticipating his race in the Breeder's Cup for months - with or without Curlin - and will sorely miss him. He was a joy to watch - when he got going, it was like looking at perfection. He did what he was created to do and enjoyed it while he was doing it. I'll miss him.

Karen in Indiana 17 Oct 2008 11:24 AM

Very interesting article. I've never seen a heel injury that bad although I've seen ones that were as bad after they have healed.

I talked about BB's feet on Jason's site all year and I did comment about what appeared to be patches on his heels in the Monmouth Stakes. I was told it was dirt but I didn't buy that one it didn't look like dirt.I realize now that his feet were a work of art with alot of the foot missing. when he grabbed himself in the work he took off the patch and some real foot with it.

They were quoted as saying that he had never done that before(bull poop). If a horse isn't right on the front end they will hit or grab themselves because they are not travelling right. IMO it's disgusting that they carried on with him knowing what they knew. These guys should be ashamed of themselves putting their interests above that of the horse. I have zero respect for the connections and all the respect in the world for the horse. To do what he did with the feet he had shows he had a ton of heart.

Wanda 17 Oct 2008 11:35 AM

I love Big Brown and pray for his comeplete healing.  I would have loved to have seen him compete in the Breeder's Cup, racing against many other great horses, including my other favorite, Curlin.  If he won, that would have been great.  But if not, he still got to compete.  Now we will never know what else he could have achieved.  On the bright side, now he gets to go the Three Chimneys and make "little" Big Brownies.  God speed beautiful boy.

HaleyB 17 Oct 2008 6:27 PM

Leave a Comment

All comments are moderated and must be approved before they are posted. The blog author reserves the right to edit or omit any comment.

  (Appears with your comment) (required)
  (Will not be published) (required)
  (required)

Thoroughbred Bloggers Alliance

Thoroughbred Bloggers Alliance RSS Feed

Click Here to download BloodHorse.com Widgets!