Home

0561727
Ratings Generated in 2012
Featured Stallion

A Nick in the Making? Indian Charlie and Storm Cat

In the last couple of years we have been experimenting with crossing Indian Charlie (TrueNicks,SRO) over Storm Cat-line mares. It's not a cross that has been much tested yet, although Indian Charlie does have a listed stakes winner out of a mare by Hermitage (by Storm Cat's sire, Storm Bird). However, we had a strong conviction that the cross had potential, particularly over mares that were by Storm Cat/Raise Native crosses, or that were themselves bred on the cross.

The reason? Indian Charlie's dam, the very speedy Soviet Sojourn, is by Leo Castelli. In turn, his sire is by Sovereign Dancer, who is a Northern Dancer/Bold Ruler cross, as is Storm Cat. We can note that there are already at least five stakes winners with Storm Cat in the sire and Sovereign Dancer in the dam. Two of these are by Giant's Causeway (TrueNicks,SRO) and Forestry (TrueNicks,SRO) , but the other three are by the far less high-profile Storm Boot, High Yield, and Sea of Secrets. It's also interesting that four of them are out of mares that stem from the direct Sovereign Dancer line. So, the cross has enjoyed success, despite being through the generally underperforming male line/male line cross.

The reason we like the Storm Cat/Raise a Native cross in the dam here is because Leo Castelli is out of a Raise a Native mare, making him a virtual parallel to horses like Tale of the Cat (TrueNicks,SRO) and Forest Wildcat. For good measure, Indian Charlie's second dam is by Diplomat Way, a Nasrullah/Princequillo cross, like Storm Cat's broodmare sire, Secretariat.

Anyway, the weekend gave some encouragement with regard to our theory, this in the shape of Navigator, a (then-) 2-year-old filly who captured the Blue Norther Stakes at Santa Anita. Navigator is by Stormy Atlantic (TrueNicks,SRO) , who had a good weekend, with another 2-year-old, Not Grounded, taking the Calcasieu Stakes at Delta Downs. He now has four 2008 juvenile stakes winners, also including graded winner Bittel Road.

What made Navigator particularly interesting to us, however, is that she is out of a mare by Indian Charlie, so is a reverse of the Indian Charlie/Storm Cat cross. Navigator is only the second stakes winner out of an Indian Charlie mare, and is also only the second starter that we can find by a son of Storm Cat out of an Indian Charlie mare (the other, Heather's Angel, was an allowance winner at Saratoga this summer).

Filed under:

5 Comments:

Hi Alan,

Is the Cross of Horse Chestnut over a mare bred on the Northern dancer/Habitat cross a good Nick? A Happy New Year 2u Alan.

trevor 03 Jan 2009 3:30 PM

APorter, Storm Cat is one of the worst broodmare siring grandson of Northearn Dancer. The Northern Dancer broodmare line is one of the most successful in Triple Crown history. Storm Cat is the poorest extension of of this potent broodmare line.

The 2007 issue of the Blood-Horse Stallion Register reflects Storm Cat as siring 328 dams of 1188 foals with 686 runners. None of these dams have produced the winner of a Triple Crown race. Storm Cat's 110 sons are no better in this department as well.

m palmer 04 Jan 2009 12:24 AM

to M Palmer, Woke Up Dreamin is outta a Storm Cat dam and all he did was win back to back Grade II's. True North, The Smile... He finished number 8 on the broodmare sire list, Storm Bird finished number 18. Storm Cat still draws attention in the sales ring as well. Point taken about the triple crown, he gets some of the best mares every season...

todd 05 Jan 2009 2:56 PM

Re Storm Cat as a broodmare sire. Firstly, it is worth remembering he started very inexpensively, so a lot of his first daughters didn't have great female families which say, as a comparable, his own broodmare sire Secretariat did.

Secondly, he is already broodmare sire of nine grade one winners, including Champion Sprinter Speightstown (now a very promising young sire), Champion Two-Year-Old Folklore, Sky Mesa (another promising young sire), as well as Jump Start (a promising, good value sire). They may not be classic horses, but this isn't a bad start.

Alan Porter 05 Jan 2009 9:24 PM

Hi Trevor,

Happy New Yaer. I can't see any reason for Horse Chestnut working with Northern Dancer/Habitat in general, so it would really depend on what the Northern Dancer is.

Alan Porter 05 Jan 2009 9:28 PM

Leave a Comment

All comments are moderated and must be approved before they are posted. The blog author reserves the right to edit or omit any comment.

  (Appears with your comment) (required)
  (Will not be published) (required)
  (required)